Willard Airport

Based on the University's financial reports (http://www.obfs.uillinois.edu/common/pages/DisplayFile.aspx?itemId=919122), Willard cost $4.8M to operate in fiscal year 2008.  According to Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airports_in_Illinois), there were 98K enplanements (roundtrip passenger) in 2008.  That works out to just under $50 per enplanement.  It looks like you can take a Greyhound bus to Bloomington for about $35 roundtrip.  A savings of $15 per passenger times nearly 100K passengers per year could save the customers nearly $1.5M per year.  That would represent a just under 40% increase in use at Bloomington which might increase their costs somewhat but presumably those would be offset by increased customer base to spread those costs across and lower ticket prices resulting from more passengers using the facility, assuming the facility could handle the increased traffic without requiring a major expansion.  Based on my limited experience, BMI is not operating at full capacity currently, however, so I would suspect that with the proper scheduling they could absorb this increase.

So here are the questions: Would it be a good idea to close Willard, particularly in light of the pending end to the University's aviation program and therefore its justification for maintaining ownership of a commercial airport?  Should resources currently expended to attract and retain customers and airlines be consolidated and focused to Bloomington, just an hour away, perhaps with BMI even offering direct bus service from Illinois Terminal to coincide with flights?  Or is the benefit of a local airport to the community and area businesses great enough to pay the extra costs and avoid the hourlong commute for 200K passenger-trips per year?  What do you think?

Forums (1):Discussion Forum

Comments

News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

Mike Y wrote on February 15, 2011 at 8:02 am

Prior to the expansion of

Prior to the expansion of Bloomington & Willard a true regional airport should have been built at Clinton or Farmer City and then shared by Bloomington, Decatur, Lincoln & CU. Service would have been much better and driving distances closer than St. Louis, Indy or Chicago.

bluegrass wrote on February 14, 2011 at 3:02 pm

I'm not a frequent flier - I

I'm not a frequent flier - I probably use the airport maybe twice a year. However, Bloomington almost always has a better deal for me if I'm not using Southwest out of Midway than does Willard.

Is the U of I or the State of Illinois underwriting the cost of the airport? I guess it depends on the airport making money. Who is in charge of the airport? Who would make the decision to stay open or close it?

thechampaignlife wrote on February 15, 2011 at 12:02 pm

I also an an infrequent

I also an an infrequent flier, having never flown from Willard (though family has and I've had nothing but good experiences there) and from Bloomington once (very pleasant experience). Bloomington actually is pretty well centered for this area, being roughly an hour from Champaign, Peoria, and Decatur. Merging all those airports would bring around 640K enplanements per year and make it the largest airport in the state outside of Chicago.

Speaking just of Willard, however, nearly $1M of Willard's income was derived from state appropriations and federal grants in fiscal year 2008 (federal grants appear to be quite variable as the total was over $4.4M in 2007) so I think $1M worth of tax dollar subsidies per year would be eliminated and the remaining $500K in savings per year would go into the fliers' pockets.

Without tax dollar subsidies, I think Willard would be in the red on the order of $2M per year. I believe the U of I is in charge of the airport and they would be the ones to keep it open or close it.

thechampaignlife wrote on February 15, 2011 at 12:02 pm

A quick glance at Google Maps

A quick glance at Google Maps seems to show a nearly continuous rail line (except for about 8 miles between Mansfield and Farmer City) between downtown Champaign and Bloomington's airport so potentially a small commuter train could make the runs to the airport instead of a bus if that were found to be cheaper. I'm not very familiar with rail costs so I can't speak too much on that, though. Peoria also appears to have a rail connection to BMI. That could open up an option for rail connections between these cities for regular travel as well which could access a high speed rail link should the proposed one for Bloomington ever materialize.