For some students, apartment experience doesn't match expectations

CHAMPAIGN — Allie Howry was craving the rich college experience friends were having and thought she had found the right place to get it in Champaign.

The 20-year-old Parkland College student is carrying a full academic load this semester while working 30 hours a week at a job she loves.

"I'm from Clinton. Our nights consist of driving around in a car with people you know. I just really wanted the experience of meeting new people, being around new things," she said.

While registering at Parkland, Howry asked people around her where they thought was a good place to live. After checking their suggestions online and in person with her parents, she signed a lease at University Village, a north Champaign apartment complex on Moreland Boulevard west of Market Place Mall that caters to college-age students.

The 240-unit complex was known as 88 West from the time it opened in summer 2006 until just a couple of months ago.

With amenities such as roommate matching, affordable apartments with individual bedrooms and bathrooms, a clubhouse, gym, study room, and the chance to have her dog live with her, Howry was hooked.

"My leasing agent did an awesome job. I asked her many times, 'Am I going to have fun here, fit in here? Is this a busy place?' I wanted that experience," she said.

She moved in in late August, placed with three women from the Chicago area she didn't know and with whom she had little in common, despite having filled out a lengthy questionnaire on interests for the purpose of finding compatible roommates.

After a month there — she moved to a second apartment after a week with the first roommates — Howry got exposed to some life experiences that sent her packing back home to Clinton and trying to get out of her lease.

Among the things she witnessed: people blocking stairwells while smoking cannabis, drinking alcohol and refusing to move; people sitting on her car; a woman bashing a man's head with a lamp; a brawl among 30 or more in the parking lot; and being the subject of sexually suggestive remarks from men she didn't know who followed her to her car and her apartment door.

On at least two occasions, she called Champaign police about larger fights after getting no response from guards who provide security for the nine buildings in the complex.

Howry's roommate, Jenny Gadbury, 20, originally from Mahomet, also moved in in late August and was equally excited about the place, especially getting to have her dog with her. Gadbury is a full-time Parkland student who works about 30 hours a week at a downtown Champaign restaurant and bar.

Like Howry, she saw groups hanging out in the parking lot, heard loud music coming from cars and witnessed fights. She was willing to tolerate most of that — but when she learned shots were fired at a man early on the morning of Sept. 11, that clinched her decision to move out.

"I talked to a police officer ... who said, 'If you were my daughter, you would be out of here,'" she recounted. "I come home at night (after closing the bar), and I don't want to be in the middle of that."

Howry, Gadbury and their mothers met with property manager Mitch Kesler on Sept. 21 to talk about the perceived problems and were told they could not be let out of their leases simply because they didn't feel safe.

"The management said everything in Champaign is like this. That's upsetting to me (that I didn't get that college experience). I'm 20 years old. Parkland was the best option because I get to keep a good job. Now where do I go to do this?" Howry asked. "I understand there are going to be incidents, but these are dangerous.

"This is not a bunch of kids getting drunk and being loud. It's scary things."

Gadbury added that she's willing to risk a bad credit rating to get out of her lease.

"My safety is more important," she said.

***

Records from the Champaign police department show there were 377 calls for service to 88 West in 2010, an average of just over one a day.

Less serious calls ranged from one for underage drinking to a high of 54 for loud music. The more serious included five for shots heard, two for armed people, two sexual assaults, one for home invasion, 17 for burglary, 17 for fighting, and 19 for theft.

In 2007, calls totaled 243; in 2008, there were 382; and in 2009, there were 276.

As of Sept. 13, the number of calls were apace with last year's. There had been 289, including one shooting, one stabbing, three armed subjects, and three shots heard. The number of burglaries — 25 — had already exceeded the number for all of 2010.

And on Sept. 22, police received a home invasion report in which three people said they were robbed by two men they didn't know about 12:20 a.m. No one was injured.

Champaign police Lt. Jon Swenson, who commands patrol officers in the city's north and northwest districts, said the calls may be higher than average, but it's because the people living there are college freshmen and sophomores, the vast majority of whom attend Parkland College.

"These are kids who are out of the house for the first time, not under the control of mom and dad and not subject to the rules," he said. "Over the last few years, when we've seen what you or I would classify as serious crimes, it's not being committed by someone who is a resident there.

"Underage drinking, loud music, disorderly behavior, you have to expect a certain amount of that at a complex occupied by college-age kids. That's not going to be significantly different than any other complex."

As for the burglaries, Swenson said there are two things at play. One is that the apartments are furnished with flat-screen televisions attractive to thieves, and the other is that the apartments are frequently left unlocked.

"Those are not really three- and four-bedroom apartments. They are apartments with three or four bedrooms to rent," he said, noting that people who are strangers are often put in the same units. Each person has his own bedroom that locks. The television is in the living room.

"You have three or four kids sharing an apartment who are all on different schedules and they wind up leaving doors unlocked. There are females who leave the door open for another female so they're not fumbling for a key at 2 a.m.," he said.

"Obviously a shots fired or armed subjects is a serious call of significant concern to us. We're not going to treat it any differently in terms of response than if it were at Countrybrook or Dorsey Homes."

But Swenson points out that even at one call a day, only a small percentage of the complex's total crimes are serious.

"I know that doesn't make Mom feel any better. There's not an acceptable number of times when shots can be fired," he said.

Most of the calls for service are between 7 p.m. and 3 a.m. on Thursday through Saturday nights and Sunday morning.

The complex has its own security officers, but they are not present around the clock.

***

Kesler lives in the complex and has managed it since August 2009.

There are private security guards on the property every day after the main office closes, he said. That's at 7 p.m. Monday through Friday and 6 p.m. on Saturday and Sunday.

Their presence is heavier on the weekends.

"I've been in this business 12 years, and I have managed three other properties in town," Kesler said. "The same things go on at other places. It's unfortunate. We have probably done more than others to help rectify the situation."

The complex installed security gates about a year ago. Tenants insert an access card to get through the gate. Guests can call the resident's cellphone from a box at the gate. The resident has to dial a code to let the guest in the gate.

Criminal background checks and credit checks are done on prospective tenants. The management has a no-tolerance policy, meaning that any resident caught engaging in criminal activity can be evicted, Kesler said.

He said the crimes happening at University Village are not random.

"They happen because people are hanging around with people they shouldn't be hanging around," Kesler said. "Nobody has been physically shot. If there was a sex assault, I don't know about it. It's not easy to obtain police reports.

"The issue really is, more than anything, society. A lot of kids don't have a lot of respect for much of anything. They're young kids coming from larger cities," he said, estimating that 75 percent of the tenants attend Parkland College.

He conceded that tenants sometimes like to gather in parking lots to socialize and that the loudness and drinking are partially due to their immaturity.

"There's a difference between loitering and sitting on the steps. They are all friends. We try to get them to go down by the pool or the common areas," he said.

Howry said there are signs posted at several places on the property that say loiterers can be ticketed, but Swenson said police can't do much unless the person is doing something blatantly illegal.

"We don't write loitering tickets," he said, adding that only the management has the authority to ban someone from the property.

Kesler said even if there were security 24 hours a day, things would still happen.

"When somebody fired a gun three weeks ago, I had more complaints from tenants about security being tougher on them than I did about somebody shooting the gun," he said. "As far as residents go, very rarely is there a resident that has an issue because they were in the wrong place at the wrong time. Typically, when they have issues, there's a reason something happened like people hanging out with people they don't know, advertising a party on Facebook then having items stolen.

"Pay attention to your surroundings. Make sure you know who's in your home. Lock the doors," Kesler said, sounding like a crime prevention officer.

Comments

News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

ROB McCOLLEY wrote on October 17, 2011 at 9:10 am
Profile Picture

Great hard news piece. Mary Schenk continues to be the best in the business.

ROB McCOLLEY wrote on October 17, 2011 at 9:10 am
Profile Picture

If "fun" is a priority, if "busy place" is regarded as a positive attribute; well, now you know about euphemisms in real estate marketing.

... and if "allows dogs" is what you consider a **good** quality in a high-density residential complex; you're either not looking for peace and quiet, or you have a lot to learn.

Unfortunately, if those were the parameters of the negotiation, a lawsuit for breaching warranty of habitability seems like a stretch.

pk1187 wrote on October 17, 2011 at 10:10 am

The problem is they accept section 8. Don't ever live in a complex that accepts section 8. I had no idea what it was before going to UIUC, but all of those north C-U complexes accept section 8 and it is a terrible environment to live in.

For example, during the summer of 2007 I was at the complex on north Lincoln in Urbana when about 20 police units showed up during the day. I don't know what they were there for but it was crazy.

ROB McCOLLEY wrote on October 17, 2011 at 2:10 pm
Profile Picture

I'd be interested in seeing verification/denial of this Section 8 claim.

cheezit wrote on October 18, 2011 at 11:10 am

Section 8 is not the sole problem. It's just like anything else. You have both good and bad people that make use of a Section 8 Voucher. If the apartment complex accepts them and they pass the credit/criminal background check they are approved.

Cameras would help the complex, it will not solve the problem. Security should be helping, it will not solve the problem.

They suffer from a combination of problems at that complex. It takes everyone being involved to right this wrong. It takes good management, good law enforcement and the residents involvement to make it right. If one aspect is not doing their part, it will be what it is.

It's easy to point fingers. It's hard to actually do something about it. People don't like hard.

dcaric692 wrote on October 17, 2011 at 10:10 am

There is a valuable lesson in this article for parents of college aged students. Do research about the area and call the local police department before you sign any lease.

As a parent you need to help your child choose safe surroundings over fun and many activities available.

I had never thought of this before reading this article.

jdmac44 wrote on October 17, 2011 at 3:10 pm

There are lots of people on campus who are out of the house for the first time, but the behavior there is nothing like the former 88 West, it's a whole different type of people living there, I think the police record speaks for itself.

jdmac44 wrote on October 17, 2011 at 3:10 pm

From 10/17/11 Police Reports:

ARRESTS: SLAUGHTER AKEMIE AGE: 19 SEX: F 2001 MORELAND #5-304 CHAMPAIGN IL CHARGE: BURGLARY RESIDENTIAL 720-5/19-3 BURGLARY RESIDENTIAL, etc...

From 10/16/11

ARRESTS: HULL WILL AGE: 20 SEX: M 2011 MORELAND #5-110 CHAMPAIGN IL CHARGE: FORGERY 720-5/17-3 FORGERY AT: 2011 MORELAND 5-110 BY: SUMPTION,ROBERT DUSTIN

ARRESTS: CARR ADAREUS J AGE: 21 SEX: M 2011 MORELAND #5-110 CHAMPAIGN IL CHARGE: UNLAWFUL POSS/USE WEAPON BY FELON 720-5/24-1.1 UNLAWFUL POSS/USE WEAPON

ARRESTS: DUNBAR ANTHONY T AGE: 18 SEX: M 2001 MORELAND #13 CHAMPAIGN IL
CHARGE: RECKLESS DRIVING 625-5/11-503 RECKLESS DRIVING CHARGE: RESISTING/OBSTRUCTING OFFICER

These are offenders from two days of reports who list their address at 2001 Moreland Blvd. They don't sound like minor offenses to me. One resident is a convicted felon! Are we in denial of reality or what!! lol

Find CPD report archives here...
http://archive.ci.champaign.il.us/cpd-reports/

Ryder wrote on October 17, 2011 at 6:10 pm

While in Champaign, I remember looking at 88 West and ultimately chose to not lease there. I did spend several years in other similar complexes offering comparable amenities and services (by-the-bedroom leasing w/ roommate matching, free high speed internet, pool, spa, etc.).

The risk for the tenant at any apartment complex is the rapid degradation of the living conditions from the time you sign through the length of the leasing period. In my personal experience I found these larger complexes to be particular susceptible to such a phenomenon. When I first lived in what was then known as Sterling University Fields in Savoy, it was quiet, well-maintained, and full of young professionals and grad students who largely kept to themselves. But very quickly it became overrun with younger, party-happy, undergrad-aged tenants who brought noise, assaults, vandalism, littering, and other disruptions to the quality of life.

The larger complexes were owned by big companies without a lot of attachment to the C/U area; their focus was maximizing profit and not maintaining a positive tenant experience. Ownership changed hands time and again while I was leasing at these places, and each time the experience continued to get worse. Never again will I live in such an arrangement.

lcoil79 wrote on October 17, 2011 at 10:10 pm

As someone who used to deliver to the Sterling Court area into the wee hours of the morning, I have to agree. The Sterling area used to be a great location to deliver to with friendly people and little to no problems. The downturn in clientele came when the University started housing their football and basketball players there, at that point Sterling Court became a total hellhole to deliver to.

cgadbury1 wrote on October 17, 2011 at 8:10 pm

I am featured in this article, along with my roommate Allie. She asked that this not be put online for the very reason of people posting comments, but against our wishes here it is. We feel we were not represented very well. The article made it sound like it was our first experience out on our own... it's not. I myself have lived in 3 different apartments in Champaign and NEVER experienced anything like this place. Unless you live here you have no idea how awful it is. When signing the lease they tell you its under new management and secure, totally different than how it used to be.. it's only gotten worse. And by the way, the property manager featured in this article, Mitch Kessler- QUIT. That tells you a lot, he didn't even want to deal with it anymore. "Lock your doors and you'll be fine," he said. That didn't keep people from robbing a girls' apartment Saturday afternoon. There is no real solution, unless they kick out all the thugs there nothing will change, but they can't since that makes up the majority of people living there. If you are a respectable stuent going somewhere in life don't live here.

lcoil79 wrote on October 17, 2011 at 10:10 pm

Why is it we are getting a news story that was featured on the front page over a week ago represented now as new news?

cgadbury1 wrote on October 18, 2011 at 11:10 pm

It's because my roommate and I didn't want this featured online in the first place...

News by Date