Health care merger questioned
URBANA — Olivia Brown of Urbana says she'd like to get her medical care through Provena, but so many of Provena's doctors have left.
Will a merger Provena Health is seeking with Resurrection Health Care improve access to care for patients like her? she wonders.
"I want to be a Provena patient, but all my doctors are gone," she said at a public hearing Tuesday before a state review panel that will decide whether Provena and Resurrection can go forward with their merger plans.
The merger would create the largest Catholic health care system in Illinois — bringing together 12 hospitals operated by Mokena-based Provena and Chicago-based Resurrection, among them two Provena hospitals in Urbana and Danville.
The two organizations also have 28 long-term care and senior residential facilities, more than 50 primary and specialty care clinics and six home health agencies.
The merger is set to come before the Illinois Health Facilities and Services Review Board for a hearing and possible decision at its Oct. 12-13 meeting in Joliet.
Mike Brown, regional CEO of Provena Covenant and Provena United Samaritans medical centers, said the merger will benefit the local hospitals and their roles as major employers in their communities.
But John Hilty of Urbana said the prospect of the merger makes him uncomfortable because he believes the larger an organization becomes, the less responsive it becomes, and the larger the organization, the more likely it is to engage in lawsuits.
He also said he doesn't necessarily believe a larger organization will reap financial benefits from economies of scale because health care organizations aren't a store. They're labor-intensive, and larger organizations don't necessarily bring lower prices for consumers.
Hilty and several speakers questioned what kind of financial assistance policies for needy patients a larger, merged Provena and Resurrection organization will have.
Valerie McWilliams, managing attorney for the Land of Lincoln Legal Assistance Foundation in Champaign, said Provena's financial assistance policy has been a moving target over the past decade.
However, she said, the merger presents an opportunity to improve the financial assistance programs of all 12 hospitals involved.
Research done by Champaign County Health Care Consumers found Provena hospitals gave more financial assistance (as a percentage of their net income) than Resurrection hospitals did in 2009 reports.
Provena hospitals ranged from 1.8 percent to 3.5 percent in financial assistance, and Resurrection hospitals ranged from 0.3 to 2 percent, with most of their hospitals below 1.2 percent.
Claudia Lennhoff, executive director of Health Care Consumers, said Provena has agreed to involve community advocates in crafting the new financial assistance policy for the merged organization, and her organization looks forward to collaborating with Provena at its corporate system level.
Thomas Nehring, Provena's system senior vice president for mission services, said the two Catholic health care providers will work together to create a system that is accessible and available to everyone.
"Today, the needs of the poor and the marginalized are greater than ever," he said.
I love that this article offers so many comments from key players in this merger. But 5% of this article has an extensive statement from an unknown gentleman. Does Mr.Hilty carry commercial insurance? Is he eligible for state assistance? Is he a Provena patient as Ms. Brown is? I hope Provena's financial assistance stats will come back into play the next time they are fighting for their Non-For-Profit status. This article has made it clear that Provena offers a great service to the underinsured and there is no mention of the assistance program that Carle offers. G082311
According to their respective annual reports:
Provena Cov charity care in 2010 - $5.4million
Carle charity care in 2010 - $11.5 million (more than double Provena's)
Carle clearly provides more charity care to the neediest of this community, and it appears from their respective web sites that Carle's charity care program is more generous in terms of how high its program goes relative to Federal Poverty income levels and percentage discounts available.
It sounds like this merger is simply a legal move to try to get the tax exemption back for provena. I wonder why none of the papers around here are doing a story on the fact that Provena in Danville is having their medicare authorization revoked because the DHHS feels that their care is a clear and present danger to the patients.
Actually, this merger is a legal way for a major Chicago-based healthcare entity (Resurrection), to get a foothold in an area already saturated with hospitals (something that keeps them from being able to move south). So, the best thing to do is to merge with another Catholic-based company out of Chicago (that also happens to have hospitals south of I-80), to allow them into a market they've never been allowed into.


More






Comments
News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.