Mental health court: Trading treatment for shot at forgiveness

Mental health court: Trading treatment for shot at forgiveness

URBANA — An open bag of potato chips was her undoing. Or her lifeline, depending on your perspective.

The 28-year-old Champaign woman went in a local grocery store last summer during a psychotic episode, opened a bag of chips and began eating them. Her arrest for misdemeanor theft was her ticket into Champaign County Mental Health Court.

Eleven months later, she's no longer under the watchful eye of the team of legal and social service specialists who comprise the county's latest foray into alternative justice modes.

"When she graduated, it was because she had been taking groups and had signed up for another session. She was lucky. She got her conviction dismissed," said Lori Kleppin, the Champaign County probation officer assigned to the mental health court team.

Although the woman's criminal case is a public record, The News-Gazette is not using her name because of medical privacy. Further, anonymity for the defendants allowed attorneys and counselors to discuss their cases candidly.

To date, only three of the 13 people are considered graduates.

But Judge Jeff Ford, who oversees the court, prefers not to use that term.

"We don't want them to think they're done," he said of the lifelong process that managing mental illness is.

"With mental health court, the final goal is to have them stabilized with services they need in the future," said Ford, who also oversees Champaign County's other alternative justice model, drug court.

Both aim to deliver as many services as possible in about a year in hopes that the client will improve. Of the 13 in mental health court, five have entered since March.

Although similar in concept to drug court, the courts have differences.

The main one is that a defendant in mental health court is not sentenced. The defendant pleads guilty to a crime with a promise from the prosecutor that if the defendant completes the conditions laid out for him, the charge will be reduced significantly or dismissed at sentencing.

The conditions are tailored to the person's needs. Participation is voluntary.

Urbana attorney Brett Olmstead represents a recent referral.

The man pleaded guilty in February to forgery for writing checks on a parent's account without permission. Despite the number of times it had happened, the parent didn't want the son prosecuted. He had previously been sentenced to standard probation for another forgery.

"He had an apartment. He was doing really well. Then he started using (drugs) and stopped taking his medication (for mental illness), stopped reporting, and forged a check on Dad's account," said Kleppin, who had supervised his standard probation.

State's Attorney Julia Rietz, who is her office's team member in mental health court, said the man had been admitted to Provena Covenant Medical Center's psychiatric unit more than a dozen times and has substance abuse issues, depression, and bipolar symptoms, all of which are common among the mentally ill people whose actions attract police attention.

She and Olmstead agreed that mental health court appears to be the best idea for him now.

"This is my first experience with mental health court. I think it is the best placement for my client," Olmstead said. Far from having to persuade the man to try it, Olmstead said, his client wanted to be in the program.

Rietz said a better label might help the court's marketability. "Other places call it 'recovery court,'" she said.

On the man's first day in mental health court, Ford spelled out the conditions: no alcohol, no drugs, no weapons, sign releases saying the state can check into all number of aspects of your life, cooperate with counseling, submit to random drug testing, and attend all appointments, including Monday afternoon mental health court sessions in Ford's courtroom.

"You understand this is a team? We're going to talk about you and what you're doing every week. If you withdraw, since you've already pled guilty, I can impose sentence. In this program, you can be sanctioned. If you do well, we will reward you," Ford said.

(Ford said that unlike drug court, where a harsh sanction usually involves jail time, a sanction in mental health court might be picking up litter from in front of Community Elements. A reward can be anything from praise in open court to a gift certificate to McDonald's.)

"This sentence is going to be held over your head. If you cooperate and do everything you're supposed to, this will be a misdemeanor and the felonies will be dismissed. If not, if you mess up, you come back here and be sentenced on this forgery case. It could be the penitentiary or probation and fines," Ford explained.

That felony-dismissal, carrot-and-stick approach is a big deal to some, said Becky Griffith, a specialty courts clinician with Community Elements and mental health court team member.

"It's all different for everyone. For some, it (a criminal conviction) doesn't matter. For others, it's a huge deal because of jobs, futures, careers. I see that a lot with drug courts. Felonies make it very difficult to get jobs," she said.

Griffith observed that many clients with mental illness receive disability payments from Social Security, so keeping a conviction off a resume is of little consequence to them.

Trying to keep them occupied in appropriate activities is part of Griffith's job.

"We're helping them find structured activities like volunteering, group sessions, social skill learning — doing something besides sitting at home and isolating," she said.

Griffith's colleague, Ed Hawkes, observed that with drug court clients, the goal is to keep them drug-free and crime-free for at least a year.

"With mental health court, it's more harm reduction. Preferably, we'd like to see clean drug tests or not dirty as often," he said. "We try to get people to the maximum level of recovery for them."

Hawkes said that can include attending group sessions to learn skills for how to manage their symptoms and to function in the community.

"We're talking social, communications, living skills — even as basic as diet and hygiene, the kind of stuff that a lot of us take for granted," he said. "We get up, wash our hair, brush our teeth. We have people who don't think about it. They're in their own world and they don't even know they smell."

For the potato chip consumer, that episode was her first that attracted police attention, thus getting her into the criminal justice system.

"I've known her for a while," Hawkes said. "She's had schizophrenia since her early 20s. She was compliant with medication for a while, then started thinking she doesn't need it."

"Typically, people think they're OK, don't take their medication and end up in the hospital," he said, observing that happened to that woman.

Rietz and Ford both described her as low-functioning and not very communicative when they first saw her.

"Previously, I had seen her walking around the mall talking to herself when we first started. Now she ... smiles and has a conversation. She's still low-functioning, but she's regularly attending groups," Rietz said.

"Probably one of the most important things they did for her was give her a schedule, things to do to keep herself occupied and make sure she's taking her medication," Rietz said.

Although she's but one member of the mental health court team — others are Public Defender Randy Rosenbaum, Ford, and representatives from probation, Prairie Center and Community Elements — Rietz holds most of the cards.

That's because the ultimate decision on whether to pursue prosecution lies with her.

Rosenbaum said he was initially concerned that the time in mental health court between guilty plea and sentence could go on too long, with the sentence being held over his client's head.

"A lot of my concerns have been taken care of," he said, adding that the outcomes for the three who are now done with the program have been positive.

"All have a good foothold for what they have to do to stay out of trouble, and that is the success of mental health court," Rosenbaum said.

The other two successful clients were a woman who had hoarding issues with pets in her home and a man who threatened to harm mental health workers who answered a crisis line. They were in court almost 10 months and nine months, respectively.

Rietz said she's trying to take her cues from Hawkes and the other mental health and substance abuse workers as to how clients are doing.

"I have really encouraged the mental health professionals to lead the way rather than the judge and the attorneys," Rietz said. "If they say there are still things that can be done, we'll keep going. Once they say we've exhausted all the tools, I'll move to find someone unsuccessful."

That has happened to at least five people since the program's inception, Ford said.

Hawkes admits there is no standard treatment formula for mental illness. For those who self-medicate with alcohol and drugs, they first have to get control of their substance abuse through Prairie Center before moving on to the mental health issues.

"We have to use our best judgment from our experience (about what might work for a person). Some people we've known for a long time, we know their history," Hawkes said of how treatment plans are designed.

Hawkes and Griffith spend most of their time linking the person to the correct social service or treatment provider.

"We have to make sure they get to their doctor appointments, refer them to other services, coordinate with Prairie Center," he said.

Can the work be frustrating? Yes. Is it worth it? Yes, say team members.

"These are people with significant long-term mental health issues. Many also have substance abuse issues in addition to their mental health issues. It would be unreasonable to expect a quick cure," Rietz said.

"I think it's working," Hawkes added. "You can't expect to be a success 100 percent. Anybody you can help is going to reduce the overall cost in the long run. The people we got in needed the help and appreciated the help they've received. They didn't want to get charged with a crime."

Added Rosenbaum: "Certainly there are some things we could do better. We've improved over time. We have progress goals like what do we want them to accomplish. We need to improve on setting realistic goals. Everybody understands the goal is to get these people in the best position for them."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
EL YATIRI wrote on August 19, 2012 at 11:08 am
Profile Picture

No effective treatment for the mentally ill.  Don't believe the psychiatrists/psychologists the biggest quacks  around.

More research for effective treatment instead of bandaids!

This will be the same as "drug court" with the same dismal results.

SychoClown wrote on August 19, 2012 at 12:08 pm

Ten years ago I was one of those types of people that the article made reference to and I take great offense to the mischaracterization of the mental health field.  I was engaging in behavior that made absolutely no sense until my amazing family assisted me in getting the treatment I needed for Bipolar Disorder.  Over the last decade by following the treatment plan of my amazingly skilled mental health providers I have become a success story in life.  I work full time, completed one college degree, am working on another one, volunteer in my community and have become a functioning member of my family.  All if this was made possible by the fact that medical professionals using empirical scientific methods provided me the best treatment possible and made a difficult health problem manageable.  To suggest that the fields of psychiatry and psychology is anything less than a group of highly skilled and educated sub-specialty of medicine providing medically devised treatment programs is perpetuating a stereotype that is both misinformed and dangerous to those that make the difficult step to seek treatment. 

I appreciate the "out of the box" thinking that our criminal justice system is trying as it has the potential to save resources, provide treatment to those most in need and makes it possible for a condition out of the control of the person to not lead to a life of disconnection and despondency. 

EL YATIRI wrote on August 20, 2012 at 5:08 am
Profile Picture

I am happy for you.  Do you care about the many who worked as hard as you did to recover but were unable to?

The mental health part of medicine is primitive and not scientific.  Big pharma controls the research and supresses unfavorable or neutral studies.

Antidepressants, mood stabilizers all without even knowing their mechanism of action.

Most mentally ill do not benefit from the meds.

As long as we buy the propaganda and do not make our voices heard for better treatment, the situation will be the same.

Marti Wilkinson wrote on August 21, 2012 at 10:08 pm

I've heard that the LA County Jail has been called the largest mental health facility in our country. The current justice system of locking people up in cages, and setting them free down the road doesn't always serve as a deterrent to crime. For non-violent offenses I think it's reasonable to offer alternatives to incarceration. Granted the recovery rates for drug/alcohol addiction and mental health services don't have the best numbers. However, I hope that we can find ways to fund and support services that will improve the quality of life for people who do have issues.

For some people it's necessary to have a long-term treatment plan, and many insurance providers refuse to pay for it. As a result, people get misdiagnosed based on one or two office visits, and a questionairre. Inpatient care programs are limited by the number of beds, and the amount of money an insurance provider is willing to pay for. You almost have to be extremely poor or extremely wealthy to qualify for any kind of medical care in the current systems that are available.

The human mind has not been given the same level of serious study as the heart, and that may play a role as well. The fields of psychology and psychiatry, are still fairly new disciplines, and we aren't that far away from the days of Freud. Physical medicine has been around much longer, and has had many advances in the last century. However, the increased understanding that we have towards mental health has resulted in advocacy work by groups like NAMI. I would like to think that we've grown beyond the point of treating sick people like demon possessed souls, guilty of witchcraft, or having asylums where the mad are kept in chains and used as sideshow entertainment.


rsp wrote on August 19, 2012 at 3:08 pm

There are some "quacks" in the business just like there are in every field of medicine. And there are very effective treatments for mental illnesses. Treating an ongoing, chronic condition is not putting a bandaid on it. All chronic conditions can have flare-ups. To denegrate the mentally ill or their caregivers is wrong. The drug court program has been highly successful. Hopefully this program will do the same. 

Local Yocal wrote on August 19, 2012 at 4:08 pm
Profile Picture

Champaign County averages over 1000 drug prosecutions a year since the year 2004. Since 1999, 190 people have graduated from Drug Court. Small success.

rsp wrote on August 20, 2012 at 2:08 am

And how many of those people have gone on to re-offend? Not everyone qualifies. It runs in "classes" and there is a cost to the program. Plus it's cheaper than just locking them up. Not everyone wants to go. Some would rather just get a sentence over with. !000 drug prosecutions a year? That doesn't mean they have a drug problem. A lot of those are small time dealers. It would waste resources to put drug dealers in a drug treatment program. 

trent999mn wrote on August 20, 2012 at 3:08 am

The program is meant to help these people in sit setting there live on track and to keep them out of the legal system. However the court also take advantage of the system by placing people in to the mental health and declaring them incompetent  I didn't know that much how the legal proceeding go or went but One thing I thought learnd  was evey  person had the right to a fair and just jury trial How ever is just not true I aim speaking from excrescent for the last four year I have deal with my father who never had any mental heath issues prior to this owned and ran a successful business for 45 year this all came to a halting hold over a civil court case that has escalated by the city police courts inflecting the lost of every thing he had worked so hard for all his life such as his health, family,home , business,freedom and so on and so on the only thing Hes asked for is to go to trial how ever throw over two hundred court hearing,12 lawyers and 20 Judges going from civil to criminal to mental that put a stop on all the rest of legal back and forth with many diffident opinions  but most clam him competent  but the courts have made such a mess of this they cant convict  him of any of the numerous charges felony misdemeanors  as guilty how ever he competent to settle the court offer a plea bargain one just one of the charges of no contest he would get no jail time nothing on his record no fines and his property that seized  back what he will not take he be leave in his innocence as I also do and want a trial but by pleading his innocence the court found him incompetent  for the 2nd time the first time the hospital released him say he didn't belong there and did not fit any of there criteria there and was competent  to face trial like I say its such a mess they lock him up in St Peters  to shut him up in hopes time will pass to cover up and denial  a trial. i find myself at a lost in where or what to do in order in helping him for the last year just sorting thought paper work Court documents creating a time line and all of his civil right that have been broken in hope someone will help him get A fair trial that is his right Thank you In Hennepin .county MN.

rsp wrote on August 20, 2012 at 12:08 pm

That sounds like he needs to contact the state's guardianship and advocacy commission. They can provide legal assistance and possibly help get everything sorted out.