6 graduate programs touted for elimination

6 graduate programs touted for elimination

Several graduate programs with low enrollments in recent years are expected to be phased out at the University of Illinois.

After an extensive review of all 98 doctoral programs on the Urbana campus earlier this year, campus officials are recommending the closure of six specific doctoral programs in the areas of education, engineering and biology.

"We're in the early stages of the process," said Provost Ilesanmi Adesida, who shared the list of programs recommended for closure with members of the academic and student affairs committee of the UI Board of Trustees. The committee met Wednesday in Springfield.

The programs recommended to be eliminated include the educational doctoral degree (Ed.D.) in special education; the Ed.D. in human resources education; Ed.D. music education; Ph.D. environmental science in civil engineering; physiological and molecular plant biology concentration in the Ph.D. in biology; and the higher education concentration in educational organization and leadership Ed.D.

In addition, some programs are being considered for restructuring, which could entail reviewing the curriculum or ramping up marketing efforts, Adesida said. Those include the Ph.D. program in veterinary clinical medicine, Ph.D. in Italian, Ph.D. in Portuguese and the Ed.D. in curriculum and instruction.

The review, which grew out of a Stewarding Excellence review from 2010 but ended up becoming its own, specific review focused on doctoral programs, involved committees examining several different factors. Committee members looked at program demand, program reliance on state funds, time to degree, mentoring and advising, student publications, faculty/advisee ratios, and more. It also entailed student surveys.

"It was an introspective exercise," Adesida said. "How well are we educating our students?"

Several "low-hanging fruits" emerged because of very low enrollment, he said.

Following the extensive review, the Graduate College, which administers graduate education on the campus, plans to initiate regular reviews of Ph.D. programs on a four-year cycle.

Adesida acknowledged that there is a fear among some educators and graduate students across the country that as some colleges close humanities programs, they will wake up one morning to learn their programs have closed.

That's not happening here, he said.

"At Illinois we make sure we go through the processes," Adesida said.

As an example, he listed the master of science degree in general engineering expected to be formally eliminated by university trustees Thursday. That degree program, which has been winding down for several years, saw its final student graduate in May. The history behind its planned closure dates to 2006 when the College of Engineering (where Adesida was dean until August) changed the name of the Department of General Engineering to the Department of Industrial and Enterprise Systems Engineering. That prompted the creation of a new graduate degree in Systems and Entrepreneurial Engineering and the intent to eliminate the master's degree in general engineering.

Before they can be offered by the campus, new degree programs undergo a rigorous review process, with steps that include analysis and discussion by Academic Senate committees, said Urbana Senate Chairman Matt Wheeler. Eliminating a program is a similar process, he said, with review conducted by the senate and eventually the board of trustees.

All six programs on the list are in various stages of closure, but all will go to the senate for review and ultimately before trustees, Adesida said.


News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

Reykjavik wrote on November 08, 2012 at 5:11 pm

Well so much for the conspiracy against arts and humanities.  Jeesh, this is no fun.  I wanted to whine and wail.

moderndaycowboy wrote on November 08, 2012 at 6:11 pm

Like I said on the last article, they won't eliminate arts and humanities programs. They'll have no one to teach teh 100 level geneds if they do. 

sgdavis wrote on November 09, 2012 at 9:11 am

On the contrary, Cowboy --they have and they will continue to have underpaid and insecure adjuncts and graduate students to do that work.  Over the years I have taught an ddirected many big intro level courses -- they stopped being fun when the classes and sections got huge, and the TAs got correspondingly fewer.  Efforts are being made to reverse this, but if you have a shrinking number of tenure stream faculty (which we do), TAs earning under poverty level wages in some departments (which we do) and rising enrollments (which we do) --what will happen to quality undergrad education?  

sgdavis wrote on November 09, 2012 at 8:11 am

Hello, Reykavik -- see above.  

sgdavis wrote on November 09, 2012 at 8:11 am

The PhD in Music Education is an arts and humanties degree -- - and a storied and respected program at UI, which has been famous for its music programs for a century. (where do high school music teachers come from?) Further down in the story , the Provost says they are "looking at" two Romance language programs for reorganization or revamping.

Curriculum and Instruction and Special Ed PhD programs have been very important to the education of Illinois teachers. Where do special ed teachers come from?

What's particularly disappointing is that the Provost says the designation of so-called "low hanging fruit" was made on the basis of enrollment numbers. But graduate education isn't a popularity contest --- and at UIUC many well-respected grad programs are small and some have limited their enrollments over recent years because of budget constraints.  You don't enroll grad students you can't support, because  studying for a PhD is a long process. But then the program is vulnerable because it didn't enroll many students.

The GEO is currently defending tuition waivers for grad students -- the foundation of good graduate programs at a big University. If the UI Admin has its way and tuition waivers for graduate assistants and teaching assistants are on the table, expect more grad programs to go under "review."

Is this gnashing of teeth and wailing and whining?  No, it's a sober assessment from a professor of 30 years  of experience in public Universities.

It'd be good to hear from some people from the Ed School.


SaintClarence27 wrote on December 18, 2012 at 2:12 pm

Most teachers do not obtain PhDs, so most High School music teachers have a Bachelors in Music with a focus in Education. Up the line there is potential for a masters. PhDs are not really necessary. The same could be said for Special Ed PhD programs.