State can't declare bankruptcy

State can't declare bankruptcy

URBANA — Unlike the city of Detroit, the state of Illinois cannot declare bankruptcy. Federal bankruptcy laws don't allow it.

"It's not provided in the federal bankruptcy laws. There is a provision for municipalities and any other kind of organization in the state to go bankrupt, but not the state itself," said Professor J. Fred Giertz, an economist who is director of the University of Illinois' Institute of Government and public Affairs.

And although there has been some talk of changing federal law to permit states to reorganize their financial obligations through bankruptcy, it hasn't gone far.

"In the United States we have a federal system where the states have powers that are protected from the national government, so there's a real question about supremacy and whether the federal government can impose bankruptcy rules on the state, which is supposed to have powers that are protected from the federal government," Giertz said. "I don't think there's any likelihood it's going to be approved by Congress anytime soon."

The good thing about bankruptcy, Giertz said, "is that it structures an insolvency. Bankruptcy makes the bankrupt organization go to court and then there's an orderly process in dealing with the obligations they have."

That's part of Illinois' current financial problem where pension payment obligations are shoving aside budgets for education, health care, higher education, corrections and more.

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush has argued that states should be able to declare bankruptcy, Giertz noted.

"States can't go bankrupt, but they can become insolvent since they can't pay their bills. The question then is, what do you do then?" Giertz said. "I think what Bush would say is that when an organization becomes insolvent, it's probably better to have some rules about how to deal with it rather than just catch as catch can.

"I'm not saying the state of Illinois is bankrupt or should go bankrupt, but in bankruptcy it's a question of who gets paid and who doesn't get paid."

In Illinois, he said, lawmakers are facing a number of pension reforms, all of which call for some level of change in retirement payment obligations.

"We're basically talking about how do we give pensioners a haircut? When they talk about pension reform, it's really pension default, with the question being how do they handle the default. The argument could be that it might be better ... to have more structure to that rather just an ad hoc sort of thing."

Another rhetorical question from Giertz: "Why are state bondholders protected when state pensions are not? There might be a good reason for that, that you want to issue bonds in the future. But if the state is in such dire shape that it has to renege on its pension obligations, why not include the bondholders in the game as well? Now, it's sort of an hoc thing where if there was a bankruptcy, it would have been more formal."

Giertz believes there are many local governments "doing much worse than the state of Illinois. The fire and police pensions are usually done at the local level and there are all sorts of problems there in particular, a lot of municipalities have given away the store in terms of benefits. The state of Illinois, its problem has been underfunding. And the problem with local governments is that when you have a city, people can just move away. They're not probably all going to move away from the state of Illinois.

"So a city can be left high and dry. That kind of movement, like in Detroit, makes it even worse for a local government."

Sections (2):News, Local

Comments embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

Joe Melugins wrote on July 20, 2013 at 9:07 am

In Moody's recent downgrade rating of Illinois, Moody's stated, "Illinois still has a diverse and large economic base, with above-average wealth levels."

 That doesn't sound like a state anywhere close to bankruptcy to me.  Their report is available at:


urbana_resident wrote on July 21, 2013 at 3:07 am

It sounds like an alarming signal that Illinois is sooner or later to go broke. Drive through while you can.

gollygeewillikers wrote on July 21, 2013 at 7:07 am

Get ready for the 100 billion dollar shortfall headlines. 

Political Observer wrote on July 25, 2013 at 1:07 pm

I'd like to personally thank Tom Kacich for writing this succinct, informative article!  I especially like single-sourced articles that quote only a conservative economist from a prominent local Republican family!  (Sometimes, after you've heard the conservative side of the issue, of course, there's just no longer any need to hear from anyone else, anywhere else on the political spectrum!)
I also greatly appreciated that Professor Giertz, in his precise and insightful comments, was able to work in some remarks by the truly brilliant and distinguished Former Florida Governor,  John Ellis "Jeb" Bush (who might be running for President of the U.S. in 2016, you know, so it's good to get his name out there)!
Yes, if there's one family in this country that I want to hear more about in regard to issues of budgeting and finance, why, it's definitely the Bush Family!  Jeb's brother, George W.,for instance, made such a wonderful decision in hiring Mr. Mitch Daniels as his budget director, that we were able to benefit from exemplary budgeting and fiscal policies during the George W. Bush administration!  (Indeed, many of us are still benefiting from those wonderful times!  Further, despite Mr. Mitch Daniels' slightly underestimating the cost of the Iraq War during his days in D.C., he was nevertheless welcomed back home with open arms in his home state of Indiana, and he's since gone on to a distinguished career as Governor of Indiana and the President of Purdue University!...Thereby illustrating the old Republican adage, "If you must Fail at Something, well then, boy, at least be sure to Fail Large, and Fail Upwards!")
So, once again, I'd like to sincerely thank Tom Kacich for exemplifying that tried and true motto of the News-Gazette:
"Real news is the product we sell. It is gathered, reported and edited by trained and experienced profesionals who subscribe to a code of ethics never knowingly to mislead or publish for personal advantage. They bring - in most cases - decades of experience to the task of offering a little better understanding of the world around us. It's their job."
John Foreman, Publisher