Group wants more cleanup at Fifth-Hill site

Group wants more cleanup at Fifth-Hill site

CHAMPAIGN — Even though the white tent has come down, a community group is pressing for more environmental cleanup at a toxic site near Fifth and Hill streets.

The Fifth and Hill Neighborhood Rights Campaign restated its demands during an organizational meeting on Wednesday night: It says Ameren Illinois did not go far enough when they stopped at its property line in cleaning up contamination from a former manufactured gas plant.

The group brought in a University of Illinois professor whose graduate students studied the site. Charles Werth, a professor of civil and environmental engineering, said site contamination goes well beyond the property lines of a roughly 2 1/2 acre site Ameren Illinois owns just east of the intersection of Fifth and Hill streets.

The debate over site contamination has been ongoing for years. Though Ameren Illinois never owned the manufactured gas plant that operated on the site until 1955, it acquired the property through a series of business deals and is responsible for its cleanup.

The utility recently completed excavating soil from the property to remove contaminants, but neighbors say they still fear carcinogenic chemicals like benzene are in the groundwater and have migrated from the property to the surrounding neighborhood.

Werth said the documentation shows that soil samples taken from around the site prove that the contamination has spread into the surrounding neighborhood — in some cases, the farthest test sites from the property showed contamination levels higher than what is generally considered safe.

Werth said that means there's no definitive answer to how far the contamination has really migrated.

"Based on the documentation I've looked at, I haven't identified where the clean line for the soil contamination is once you move off the property," Werth said.

The most dangerous chemicals in the soil include benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, xylene — or BTEX chemicals — and another group called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, or PAHs.

When the plant was in operation, those chemicals were used in a process that turned coal into methane gas. A byproduct of that process was coal tar, which could have leaked out of pipes or was mishandled during an era when workers were unaware of the long-term effects. Other chemicals were found in fuels for engines that powered the plant.

Werth said those chemicals can migrate in the groundwater. It's a slow process — maybe only several feet per year — but the manufactured gas plant opened in the 1880s.

"It's had a long time to migrate," Werth said. "We're talking 100 years, so then you can begin to think about long distances that these can travel."

Ameren officials were not immediately available for comment Wednesday night, but they have maintained that the toxic site poses no threat to neighborhood residents. Ameren Illinois cleaned up the site as part of the state's "voluntary site remediation" program, and completed the final phases of that process with soil injections around the perimeter of the property earlier this year.

Serena Hou, a UI doctoral student, said follow-up tests have shown, however, that those BTEX chemicals and naphthalene, a PAH, remain near the surface around the perimeter of the property.

Claudia Lennhoff, the executive director of Champaign County Health Care Consumers, said there is not much use getting frustrated with Ameren Illinois, which has met the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency's standards for site remediation. Instead, she said, residents should turn their focus to the state agency for more cleanup.

"While I get frustrated and mad at Ameren, Ameren's going to do whatever they're allowed to do," Lennhoff said.

Lennhoff said the group wants the off-site contamination and the suspected groundwater contamination cleaned up, and it wants a pipe believed to run from the Fifth and Hill site to the Boneyard Creek removed. It also wants to make sure that manufactured gas plant waste remains out of a landfill in Clinton sitting above the Mahomet Aquifer, the source of drinking water for more than 700,000 people in 15 central Illinois counties.

The way to do that, she said, is to put pressure on regulatory agencies.

"We need to focus on the government agencies that allow or don't allow certain things to happen," Lennhoff said.

Sections (2):News, Local

Comments embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

Local Yocal wrote on October 31, 2013 at 11:10 am
Profile Picture

Here's a case where money is more important than people, so much so that science is defied.

Ameren has profits of $500 million a year. Wouldn't hurt that company to do the right thing. How the IL EPA has determined the total effects of the natural gas plant doesn't have to be entirely cleaned up, damages be compensated for, and that Ameren can dump the waste they did clean up to be placed over our source of drinking water is a political corruption scandal this newspaper won't ever investigate. Ameren is a great advertiser in this newspaper, afterall. Thanks for at least letting the little people be heard for one day.

Joe American wrote on October 31, 2013 at 11:10 am

Of course they want more.  After all, their 15 minutes are up and they haven't found another cause de jour to take up their excess time.

Local Yocal wrote on November 01, 2013 at 5:11 am
Profile Picture

Cause de jour? The contaminants have been allowed to fester for over 100 years, has harmed people for decades, and this de jour has come to a head since 2007. Yeah, poisenous waste from coal tar is just something people want to get in the newspaper about, it's not such a big deal.....cancer? Contaminating everyone's drinking water? Who cares? Go Illini!