Legislation takes aim at getting degree under false pretenses

Legislation takes aim at getting degree under false pretenses

SPRINGFIELD — A seemingly innocuous bill that would make it illegal to use a false academic degree for the purpose of getting a job, gaining access to an advanced degree program at a university or getting a job promotion was approved unanimously by an Illinois Senate committee Tuesday.

But HB 4090, which sailed through the Illinois House last month on a 91-23 roll call, has some Champaign-Urbana history to it.

And state Sen. Chapin Rose, R-Mahomet, added to the history with an amendment on Tuesday. His addition to the bill makes it illegal to obtain a degree under false pretenses, as in the case of University of Illinois instructor James Kilgore, the former Symbionese Liberation Army member who served time in a California prison for a murder during a 1975 bank robbery.

Kilgore used the name of a deceased child, Charles John Pape, to obtain a passport to escape from the United States to South Africa and to obtain a doctoral degree, Rose said.

"One way of looking at it is if you showed up today and signed up for a Ph.D. program and you weren't who you said you were, that's a stolen identity," Rose said.

Rose said the amendment ultimately may not be needed because the UI has said that it will institute background checks for new employees.

"We'll wait and see now with the U of I because they are moving some things forward with respect to background checks," Rose said. "We'll see how that goes."

The Mahomet Republican said he had not talked to state Rep. Naomi Jakobsson, D-Urbana, about the amendment to HB 4090, which was her bill in the House.

"I've not seen her to talk to her about it," Rose said Tuesday afternoon.

Jakobsson's original legislation has its own back story. She and her husband, Eric, a University of Illinois professor, were critical earlier this year of Carol Ammons, the Urbana Democrat who ran to succeed Jakobsson in the House.

They accused Ammons of promoting her degree from Walsingham University in London — a place Eric Jakobsson called "a diploma mill" — in her campaign materials.

Both Jakobssons supported Ammons' opponent, Champaign attorney Sam Rosenberg, in the Democratic primary election, but Ammons won.

Asked last month why she was sponsoring HB 4090, Naomi Jakobsson said only, "It's a good government bill. Why not?"

Meanwhile, Rose said he wouldn't bring up the Kilgore issue Wednesday when UI trustees, President Robert Easter and UI students are scheduled to be in Springfield for a lobbying day.

"I'm going to tell the president how fully supportive of the hospital concept we are. I'm going to focus on something that could be a huge economic boon for our region," Rose said of the suggestion that the UI and Carle open a medical institution in Urbana that could be used for medical teaching and education.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
UrbanaJake wrote on May 13, 2014 at 8:05 pm

Kudos to Sen. Chapin and Rep. Jakobsson. I've personally gone to Rep. Jakobsson when I had a problem with a state government office in Champaign. Her staff is incredibly great and follows-up. It was simply amazing, and she helped when I needed it.                                                                                                             That said, I want to give future Rep. Ammons a chance; we need a voice that represents all the people. I hope she is that voice and doesn't become part of Springfield's "indicted caucus:" the Feds are watching and listening, as are their rats and moles. And no, that doesn't mean to try new tricks, just play by the incredibly generous rules (who knew state reps. and senators can pay themselves from campaign funds to put out campaign lawn signs?). Independence is great; arrogance will get a person-- even a rep., sen. or guv, the slammer -- especially in our fair state.                                                                                                                                  Being an academic with an Ed.D. or Ph.D., you may be affored the courtesy title of "doctor," but any degree is meaningless when short-cuts are taken. I could go to a foreign country and get some medical degree in a year, but would you want me teaching medical school in the United States? Same with Kilgore.          And Ms. Ammons, you wisely put your name on the ballot. The voters will decide, not newspapers or boards of trustees, on your future.

Jake1938 wrote on May 15, 2014 at 12:05 am

This is from Eric Jakobsson (jake1938--not too cryptic, that is my birth year).  Just to make the record clear--I have no idea who UrbanaJake is, except it is not me.