Nasty politics part of the game

Nasty politics part of the game

Political campaigns have degenerated into a slightly more refined version of mud wrestling.

State Sen. Michael Frerichs has hit the political jackpot.

The Champaign Democrat collaborated last week with the Republican candidate he wanted to run against (John Bambenek) to embarrass the Republican candidate he didn't want to run against (Alan Nudo).

The issue the pair raised (a 2006 campaign contribution to Frerichs) was not just inconsequential but inaccurate. But it so got under Nudo's thin skin that he suddenly pulled out of the March primary race for the Republican nomination in the 52nd Senate District.

How do we know it was false? Bambenek Tuesday admitted as much.

"After having reviewed all the available information about the campaign contributions from Triple R Development to Mike Frerichs, I am convinced that Mr. Nudo played no role in the donation and is neither an owner nor a decision-maker in Triple R Development," Bambenek said.

He wasn't nearly so fastidious about the details last week when he accused Nudo of being the mastermind behind $5,000 in donations from Triple R Development, a company co-owned by Kyle Robeson and close Frerichs' relatives Lawrence and Kenneth Roessler.

In his role as president of Robeson's Inc., Nudo acknowledged that he signs checks for Triple R. But he said the donated money was not his own and that, in signing the Frerichs checks, he was carrying out the wishes of his employers.

Bambenek said last week he made the charge after he "consulted with Mike Frerichs regarding the facts."

"I am not about to lay inaccurate or wrongheaded criticism against my opponent without getting the facts first," Bambenek said.

Nudo, considered the more popular choice of the two GOP candidates, was the preferred candidate of the local and state GOP establishment. In withdrawing as he did, Nudo has let down many.

Nudo concedes that he does not have the stomach to endure the kind of negative campaigning so common in elections today, but one wonders how he could have been so naive as to not know what he was getting into.

What's next?

While Frerichs gloats, Bambenek is hoping that Republicans will unite behind his candidacy. That's less than certain.

Locally, Nudo supporters will have a bad taste in their mouths over what happened. Many will either sit out the election or support Frerichs. On a statewide basis, Republican leaders are likely to write off the 52nd District as hopelessly lost and focus their financial resources elsewhere.

While Nudo showed himself to be a candidate who couldn't take the heat, both Bambenek and Frerichs proved they aren't above misleading the electorate.

Bambenek already has conceded his errors.

As for Frerichs, he'll deny any impropriety. But he pretty much conceded he prefers running against Bambenek when he stated that "John and I have a similar interest but from a different perspective."

He also engaged in rhetorical misdirection by suggesting Nudo claimed he played no role in the donation.

"[I]t is inaccurate to say that he had nothing to do with the contributions," Frerichs said of Nudo, effectively accusing Nudo of saying what Nudo had never said.

Frerichs is an intelligent, ambitious politico who wants to move up the political pecking order. He makes a good impression, but beneath the impressive veneer beats the heart of an office seeker who will do what it takes to win.

This latest episode is a reminder of Frerichs' first political campaign, when he challenged then-state Rep. Tim Johnson in an Illinois House race. Frerichs cited what he called Johnson's lack of interest in the job by noting that Johnson had dropped his committee assignments. Further proof of Johnson's negligence, Frerichs said, was the fact that Johnson didn't even have a district legislative office.

Johnson didn't have a legislative office in the district. He used his downtown Urbana law office as a joint law/legislative office to save taxpayers' money, and that office was roughly a block from the border of his House district.

Frerichs' charge against Johnson was technically accurate, but intentionally misleading.

That's what passes for political debate these days, and those vying for political office will draw two lessons from the Nudo fiasco.

Lesson 1. Many politicians will do whatever it takes to win.

Lesson 2. Questionable tactics often work.

Sections (2):Editorials, Opinion
Categories (2):Editorials, Opinions

Comments embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

STM wrote on January 25, 2012 at 12:01 pm

Still, the NG will never call out the Republican candidate.

Sid Saltfork wrote on January 25, 2012 at 12:01 pm

Given the Republican presidential primary campaign, and the history of candidates campaigning in Illinois; this seems to be a small fish smear on a local candidate.  You have to agree that for years, and years the NG has represented the Republican point of view.  What is the difference between the local candidate's actions, and the NG's action on smearing Democrat candidates?  Oh.... we are talking about Ethics.  Well, Ethics do not exist in this county even at the u. of i.

jthartke wrote on January 26, 2012 at 9:01 pm

Three people involved in this story about a Republican Primary, and it is the Democrat's fault.  I see.  I would imagine Mike would be happy to know he has that much pull in who runs as a Republican.  And sorry for Al Nudo, but sow the breeze and reap the whirlwind.  Mr. Nudo has had his hands in his fair share of political scraps as a member of the county board.    He attacks, then cries about how unfair it is when he is hit back.  Besides, what isn't true here?  He signed those checks, and Senator Frerichs is required to keep his books open by law.