Guest commentary: Say no to new borrowing; state can't afford repeat mistakes

Guest commentary: Say no to new borrowing; state can't afford repeat mistakes


When a family is drowning in debt and interest payments, the worst thing it can do is apply for new credit cards. The additional spending power may bring short-term relief and a false sense of security, but it will ultimately lead to financial collapse.

Similarly, with state government already drowning in debt and saddled with one of the lowest credit ratings in the nation, the worst thing it can do is take out another loan. It may make the state's bill backlog look better for a few months, but it will dig us even deeper in the long haul.

Yet legislation filed in General Assembly session proposes to do just that. HB6240 would authorize state government to borrow an additional $4 billion, and take on more general obligation debt than it has in any of the previous 20 years.

As I told the House Executive Committee during testimony last week: we simply can't afford it.

To be clear, I very much understand the good intentions of this borrowing plan and appreciate State Rep. Esther Golar's effort to bring in new revenue to pay off state vendors that consistently wait months for the payments they're owed.

As state comptroller, I hear daily from not-for-profit and service agencies, schools, hospitals, small-business owners and others that are hurting because of prolonged state payment delays. Those vendors have provided a service but then are told to wait to get paid. Frankly, it's unconscionable — and it needs to change.

But borrowing is not the answer — it is actually what created this mess to begin with.

Consider: the state ended its most recent fiscal year with $27.55 billion in general obligation bonds — nearly four times what we had a decade ago. As a result, Illinois is ranked fourth-highest among states in tax-supported debt. With proposed additional borrowing, the state would pass New Jersey and carry the third-highest debt in the nation.

Like a consumer with damaged credit, taxpayers are paying the price. In fact, the nation's three bond rating agencies have downgraded the Illinois' credit a combined 11 times in the last four years. With each downgrade, taxpayers are forced to pay even more in interest when the state borrows for road, bridge, and other construction projects.

It is time to cut up the proverbial state credit cards, keep spending flat and implement structural budget changes. As our economy grows, we will slowly pay down our bill backlog and regain our fiscal footing — and do it quicker, and at less expense to taxpayers, than we would to pay off new borrowing.

By taking that approach, we will ultimately return our state to a responsible payment cycle and bring much-needed relief to our vendors and taxpayers. I'm not saying it will be easy, but as we've seen, the "easy" route often has devastating consequences. We need to learn from experience and do it right this time around.

Judy Baar Topinka has been Illinois comptroller since January 2011, making her the state's chief fiscal officer.

Sections (2):Editorials, Opinion
Categories (2):Editorials, Opinions

Comments embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

Sid Saltfork wrote on December 09, 2012 at 11:12 am

The early season for the party governor primary picks has started.  Topinka, Rutherford, and Brady have been making statements in the press.  Name recognition races have started.  Quinn is dead to the democratic party in regards to running again.  Expect democrats to issues public statements for name recognition purposes next.

Pension systems have their top leadership appointed.  The members do get to vote on some of the leadership; but the control stays with Springfield's hands.  The State Employees Retirement System got stuck with Topinka.  Too bad that her view of controlling spending was not practiced earlier in her, and others political careers.  

Illini Libertarian wrote on December 09, 2012 at 8:12 pm

Okay, I think it's time to cut our losses and let the state declare bankruptcy. Let's face it, these politicians can't be trusted to do their jobs; let's fire them and start over with a blank slate.