Attorney general gets 30 extra days

Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan gets an extra 30 days to make up her mind about asking for a concealed-carry review.

Attorney General Lisa Madigan sought and last week the U.S. Supreme Court granted her request for an additional 30 days to decide whether to seek high court review of a decision striking down the state's ban on concealed carry.

The court's decision is a good one for Madigan because she will know by the new June 24 deadline what no one knows now — whether the Legislature has responded to a federal court order to pass concealed carry and, if it does, what rules the concealed carry law will establish.

Depending on what the Legislature does, Madigan may conclude that it's unnecessary to ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review last December's ruling by a federal appeals court in Chicago. Our view is that whatever action the Legislature takes, Madigan should ask for Supreme Court review to clarify the law on a nationwide basis.

Appeals courts in two other federal circuits have taken a contrary views from that of the Chicago appeals court. That makes the issue ripe for a final resolution by the nation's highest court.

These questions and others have sewed considerable confusion in the public mind on this issue, and it's important for the public to realize what's at stake.

In recent years, the U.S. Supreme Court — by 5-4 votes — has struck down ordinances in Washington, D.C., and Chicago that barred citizens from possessing firearms. The high court ruled that the bans violated citizens' Second Amendment rights to possess firearms in their homes.

The Seventh Circuit expanded on those precedents by ruling in December that Illinois' ban on concealed carry violated citizens' right to possess firearms outside their homes. The Seventh Circuit said that states are free to draft reasonable regulations and gave the General Assembly six months, until June 9, to draft a bill.

If the Legislature does not act, citizens will be free to carry firearms without restriction, so it's important legislators establish ground rules as to who can carry, what requirements they must meet to carry and where they may carry.

So far, anti-concealed carry legislators have tried without success to pass a concealed carry that is so restrictive it allows concealed carry in name only. At the same time, pro-concealed carry legislators have failed to pass a law setting much broader broad rules.

Attorney General Madigan is opposed to concealed carry, as are virtually all Chicago-area politicians. Our suspicion is that she's hoping the Legislature passes a highly restrictive concealed carry law so she can skip asking for high court review on the Seventh Circuit decision and satisfy herself by defending any challenges to the law passed by the General Assembly.

Unfortunately, the debate and deliberations over concealed carry demonstrate political posturing by concealed carry opponents. They are the outliers in this debate.

Forty-nine states have concealed carry in some form, and there have been no huge problems as a result. Crime is reported to have gone down in some jurisdictions because bad guys don't know who's armed and who isn't.

Surely, Illinois can learn from the examples of 49 other states and act accordingly.

Sections (2):Editorials, Opinion

Comments

News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

FRO wrote on May 06, 2013 at 8:05 am

Quit dragging your feet and get on with it.  Leagal Illinois residents ARE going to have conceal carry. The way illinois law makers work, they can't make up their mind about anything.  Just keep dragging this out, by the time june 9th arrives, the whole state of illinois will let everyone carry a gun because none of them can agree on anything.  Our wonderful tax dollors at work.  Keep electing those deadbeats. 

Bulldogmojo wrote on May 06, 2013 at 11:05 am

"Crime is reported to have gone down in some jurisdictions because bad guys don't know who's armed and who isn't."

699 gun murders in Texas in 2011 that Concealed Carry couldn't and didn't prevent and they hold up concealed carry there as a panacea for preventing all crime. 

 

 

“No longer at the mercy of the reptile brain, we can change ourselves. Think of the possibilities.” ~ Carl Sagan

Sid Saltfork wrote on May 06, 2013 at 1:05 pm

I am just as concerned about the "good guys" not knowing "who's armed and who isn't" as I am about the "bad guys" not knowing "who's armed and who isn't".  Will all of the "good guys" wear white hats?  Will the "bad guys" wear black hats?  Oh... you can trust me because I am not one of the "bad guys"...........    The Fourth of July will be an interesting holiday in the future, especially the fireworks at night. 

Danno wrote on May 06, 2013 at 8:05 pm

Again, another month of waiting for one person to 'make up her mind.'