Illinois needs diet of lean cuisine

Illinois needs diet of lean cuisine

Even if Illinois could afford all the local units of government it has — and it can't — it would be foolish to keep them.

Hope springs eternal when a new year begins, and nowhere is that optimistic feeling reflected than in the New Year's resolutions people make and then, unfortunately, often forget.

But it doesn't have to be that way. Sometimes, change is so important that it becomes a necessity.

That's why the State of Illinois has to change. There's no future in committing slow-motion suicide, no matter how hard our elected officials from the top to the bottom of government try to prove there is.

That's why Andy Shaw, president of the Chicago-based Better Government Association, is proposing a resolution for the people of Illinois to embrace

"Let's tackle morbid government obesity in Illinois," Shaw urges.

Most people know what morbid obesity is, but for the uninitiated that phrase refers to growth to the point of impending death. Obese people are killing them themselves by excessive food intake, and it's Shaw's contention that Illinois is killing itself with too much government, specifically too much local government.

There's simply no disputing Illinois' excess when it coming to creating separate and independent taxing bodies. There are nearly 7,000 taxing units in Illinois' 102 counties, the most in the country. Illinois leads runners-up Texas and California, both substantially larger states than Illinois, by 2,000.

What is Shaw referring to? He's talking about municipal and county governmental units but also schools, park districts, drainage districts and townships.

Champaign County alone has 30 separate township governments, each stocked with elected officials and supported by property taxes.

Township government is a throwback to the days of a mostly agrarian society in Illinois, when transportation was limited and small governmental units really were necessary to deliver services.

Times have changed, but township government persists, operating on strength of public inertia and its own lobbying power.

There's a high cost to all the government that exists in Illinois, the duplication of services, the excessive number of elected officials jealously guarding their separate bailiwicks as they hire their brothers-in-law and the sheer foolishness of government run amok.

That's one of the reasons the State of Illinois is in a death spiral, effectively bankrupt. Cancer can be contained for a while, but when it spreads the consequences are catastrophic.

Our elected officials don't like to admit that. But the public isn't fooled for long, and eventually they vote with their feet.

That's why Illinois' population growth rate trails many other states, resulting in the steady decline in the size of the state's congressional delegation and diminished influence in Washington, D.C.

That's why Illinois ranks among the top five states in terms of people moving to a different state, according to a survey recently published by Allied Van Lines. The other four states are New Jersey, Michigan, Pennsylvania and New York.

That's why the state's budget is constantly stressed, why the state has $6 billion in old bills it can't pay, why core state functions like education are underfunded.

One of the reasons Illinois can't finance the government it does need is that it's too busy paying for the government it doesn't need.

There have been intermittent attempts to downsize government in Illinois, and they've been met with relentless hostility by the beneficiaries of morbidly obese government.

DuPage County Board Chairman Dan Cronin has led efforts to consolidate governmental units in ways that reduce costs. Democratic state Rep. Jack Franks heads a legislative commission that's been assigned to study the problem and make recommendations.

But not much will come out of these probes without an aroused public pushing state legislators and local officials to do the same or more with less government. They won't do it on their own because they face too much political resistance from the very people whose jobs and jurisdictions ought to be cut down to size.

If Illinois' ship of state is to be set on the proper course, substantive change in the form of a severe diet is mandatory.

Sections (2):Editorials, Opinion

Comments

News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

EdRyan wrote on January 05, 2014 at 8:01 am

Most of those taxing units are drainage districts with property taxes that are more of a users fee since those who are taxed benefit directly from the farm ground drainage.

If you get rid of 300 townships you'll have hardly made a dent in the total of 7,000 governments and someone will have to pick up the general assistance and rural road maintainance functions of the townships.  It sounds like quite a few people like having those small townships and they're the people paying the taxes to have them.  Maybe they like having a little more democracy instead of a little less of it.

Finally, how would this thing cost out?  Would we be replacing about 1,500 mostly very low paid, nearly volunteer, elected officials who answer directly to their taxpayers with a crew of very expensive appointed government employees answerable only to themselves?  

pattsi wrote on January 06, 2014 at 12:01 pm

Snowed like everyone else so filling time by searching on the internet to see if there has been any research as to savings should there be some government consolidation in Illinois. Lo and behold, the Illinois Policy Institute has a publication dated Nov. 2013. This publication, Too much government: Illinois' thousands of local governments, is filled with facts and figures about the many units of governments, showing overlaps and potential savings without loss of services. Actually, this is not a new topic in Illinois as noted during the internet search.

Political Observer wrote on January 07, 2014 at 3:01 am

So let's see what's happened here so far:

1.  The News-Gazette, in an unsigned editorial claims, "THE SKY IS FALLING!  ILLINOIS IS IN A DEATH SPIRAL!!  ILLINOIS HAS CANCER AND HAS TO LOSE WEIGHT OR ELSE THE CANCER WILL SPREAD AND EVERYBODY WILL DIE!  OUR ONLY HOPE IS TO IMMEDIATELY DESTROY AS MANY LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT IN THE STATE AS POSSIBLE, AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE!  DON'T TAKE TIME TO THINK ABOUT ANY CONSEQUENCES OF YOUR ACTIONS OR ANYTHING STUPID LIKE THAT, JUST DO IT, NOW!!  IT'S THE ONLY WAY TO SURVIVE!"

2.  EdRyan raises some interesting questions.  Will destroying levels of government actually save us any money?

3.  Pattsi responds to EdRyan by doing a websearch, and reports that the "Illinois Policy Institute" has produced a November 2013 publication that's "filled with facts and figures about the many units of governments, showing overlaps and potential savings without loss of services."

Hmmm...Well, isn't that convenient, that the "Illinois Policy Institute" has already done our work for us!

Political Observer wrote on January 07, 2014 at 3:01 am

But, wait a minute!  Isn't this, perhaps, a bit "too convenient?"  Who the heck is the "Illinois Policy Institute," anyway?

Well, it turns out that a little bit more research shows that the "Illinois Policy Institute" is a right-wing think tank that receives funding from a number of de-regulation-pushing, libertarian backers, as summarized here:

http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Illinois_Policy_Institute

Uh-oh!

Political Observer wrote on January 07, 2014 at 3:01 am


In fact, this article takes a bit deeper look at the "Illinois Policy Institute" and its right-wing agenda, and reports some rather interesting findings:

http://www.progressillinois.com/posts/content/2013/11/18/new-report-shed...