• Our Sites
    • The News-Gazette
      • Business Directory
      • Digital Services
      • eEdition
    • IlliniHQ
    • NewsTalk 1400 WDWS-AM
    • Lite Rock 97.5 WHMS
    • U-Rock 107.9
    • Community News
      • County Star
      • The Independent News
      • The Leader
      • Leroy Farmer City Press
      • Mahomet Citizen
      • Paxton Record
      • Piatt County Journal-Republican
      • Rantoul Press
    • Magazines
      • At Home Magazine
      • Central Illinois Business
      • I Do Magazine
      • IlliniHQ Magazine
  • LOGIN
  • Create new account
  • Login problems?
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
 
 
The News-Gazette
  • News
    • Local News
    • By Location
      • Champaign
      • Urbana
      • Danville
      • Paxton
      • Rantoul
      • Mahomet
      • Monticello
      • Tuscola
      • All Locations
    • By Category
      • Arts and Entertainment
      • Business
      • Courts, Police, and Fire
      • Education
      • Health
      • Politics and Government
      • All Categories
    • State News
    • National News
    • World News
    • Obituaries
  • Sports
    • Illini Sports
    • Prep Sports
      • All Prep Sports
      • Photo Galleries
  • Entertainment
    • Comics
    • Puzzles
    • Horoscopes
  • Multimedia
    • Photo Galleries
      • Staff
      • Prep Sports
      • User-submitted
    • Podcasts
    • Video
  • Community
    • Blogs
    • Calendar
    • Announcement Forms
    • Gas Prices
    • Best in Show 2012
    • Answerbook 2010
  • Opinions
    • Editorials
    • Discussion Forum
    • Submit a Letter to the Editor
  • Classified
    • Jobs
    • Cars
      • AutoFinder
    • Homes
    • Apartments
    • Merchandise
    • All Categories
    • Place an Ad
  • Shop
    • N-G Store
    • Deal of the Day
    • Reprints
    • Buy Photos
  • Subscribe
    • Gift Subscriptions
    • Newspaper Subscriptions
    • eEdition
    • Magazines
      • At Home
      • Central Illinois Business
      • i do
      • IlliniHQ
  • Help
    • Contact Us
      • Advertising
      • Customer Care
      • Feedback
      • News and Editorial
      • Press Release
      • Tips
    • Customer Service
    • Site Map
Home » Opinions » Editorials

More UI e-mails telling the sordid tale

Sun, 06/28/2009 - 7:54am
Facebook LikeGoogle Plus OneTweet Widget

Shoes keep dropping in the controversy surrounding politicized admissions at the University of Illinois.

It was only a couple of weeks ago that University of Illinois President B. Joseph White expressed satisfaction that a special commission had been appointed to investigate its admissions process and promised full disclosure.

Since then the UI has withheld the grades and test scores of students receiving preferential treatment, claiming disingenuously that disclosing numbers and grades was tantamount to providing the names of student applicants. It was not a profile in either logic or transparency.

But that disappointing display was small potatoes compared to Thursday's histrionics. First, there was an "emergency" four-hour board meeting in Chicago that was followed by a document dump of 123 pages of e-mail messages that had not previously been disclosed in response to news media Freedom of Information inquiries.

UI officials said the new documents had only recently been discovered and that their disclosure was proof of their commitment to an open inquiry. Well, maybe.

If so, it is an interesting coincidence that the latest batch of e-mails involving top UI officials, admissions people, trustees and power brokers make for some of the most interesting reading so far. Further, much of the material relates to admission to the UI's prestigious law school, where better qualified candidates were in danger of being pushed aside in favor of applicants targeted for derision by law school officials.

There was even one tawdry exchange involving UI trustee Larry Eppley's promise of getting five jobs, presumably in government, for UI law graduates in exchange for admitting one undeserving candidate.

That prompted an acerbic response from former law dean Heidi Hurd, "Jobs in government are fine, since kids who don't pass the bar (exam) and can't think are close enough for government work."

Former federal appeals court judge Abner Mikva, chairman of the investigating commission, expressed dismay at the turn of events.

"It's just gets thicker and thicker, and it's not good," he said.

What's easy to forget in the midst of the Keystone Cops disclosure effort and buffoonish public relations is that the UI was the target of inappropriate pressure from a variety of political power brokers, including former Govs. Rod Blagojevich and James Thompson, political thugs like Antoine "Tony" Rezko, Lon Monk and John Harris. Back-stabbing pressure was even applied from within by UI trustees who were seeking favorable admissions decisions rather than following their fiduciary responsibility to the UI. They're all saying, of course, that they were merely passing names along or expressing a slight interest in an applicant's treatment.

But it seems pretty clear that in many instances if their favored candidates weren't admitted, there would be hell to pay. At least, that's what UI officials feared, if their e-mails are any indication.

This sorry chapter in UI history is a particularly dangerous one because it strikes home with so many people interested in the education of their children. Most know, and reluctantly accept, the reality that the UI is an elite institution with hyper-competitive admissions. What they have much more difficulty accepting is that political power brokers operate on a separate track, with a secret appeals process not disclosed to everyone else, and that they get in at higher rates and with lower grades than everyone else.

For the UI to be seen as obstructing an effort to get to the bottom of this situation rather than cooperating in an effort to end it is intolerable.

It's easy to understand why top UI officials, like President B. Joseph White and Chancellor Richard Herman, don't want to be seen carrying water for some of our state's sleaziest politicians, unindicted co-conspirators and future prison inmates. It has to be hugely embarrassing because it turns everything the UI is supposed to represent upside down.

But the only way to lance this boil is to put it all out and so sicken the public and embarrass all concerned, including the politicians, that real safeguards are established to insulate the admissions process from outside pressure.

  • Login or register to post questions
  • Printer-friendly version
  • Send to friend
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Yahoo
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
Categories (2):Editorials, Opinions

Comments

News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. we reserve the right to remove any comment at its discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

#1
Wenalway wrote on June 28, 2009 at 1:06 pm

Speaking of withholding information, has Peter Fox been mentioned in an N-G story yet? Or does the N-G plan on ignoring that aspect?

  • Login or register to post comments
#2
Jsmith68 wrote on June 29, 2009 at 7:06 am

Sordid? Tawdry? Agreed this is borderline criminal. But can we avoid the National Enquirer description of events. Stick to reporting the facts, let the investigation punsish thosed needing punished. Quit trying to just sell papers.

  • Login or register to post comments
#3
publicsqualor wrote on June 29, 2009 at 11:06 am

Firing the offenders will be a half-measure at best. Until a solid firewall is erected between government leaders and university officials to guarantee the university's independence from political influence, corruption will continue.

Given the legislature's opposition to any real ethics reform, don't hold your breath for real change.

It is reassuring to know however, that as all university employees are required to take an online ethics examination each year. Maybe the test can be updated to include some questions which name Hurd and Herman's antics.

  • Login or register to post comments
#4
Wenalway wrote on June 30, 2009 at 2:06 am

"Most know, and reluctantly accept, the reality that the UI is an elite institution with hyper-competitive admissions."

Why would people "reluctantly accept" this concept? Are high standards really that hard to accept?

  • Login or register to post comments

More Like This

  • Email controversy more of the same
  • Checks from state will not be in the mail
  • Checks should be in the mail
  • The check is in the mail
  • Every picture tells a story
  • More big brother by state
  • Borrowing plan more of the same

News by Date

  • Our Sites
    • News-Gazette
      • Business Directory
      • Digital Services
      • e-Edition
    • IlliniHQ
    • NewsTalk 1400 WDWS-AM
    • Lite Rock 97.5 WHMS
    • U-Rock 107.9
    • Community News
      • County Star
      • Independent News
      • The Leader
      • Leroy Farmer City Press
      • Mahomet Citizen
      • Paxton Record
      • Piatt County Journal-Republican
      • Rantoul Press
    • Magazines
      • At Home Magazine
      • Central Illinois Business
      • I Do Magazine
      • IlliniHQ Magazine
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
The News-GazetteWHMS Lite Rock 97.5IlliniHQ.comWHMS Lite RockWDWS 1400AM Talk RadioWHMS Lite Rock
Contents of this site are Copyright ©1998-2012 The News-Gazette, Inc. All rights reserved.  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use  |  Contact Us  |  Our Clients
 Web Design/Development Champaign-Urbana