Partisan map is a public disservice

The new state congressional map, drawn in secret by Democrats, has Republicans weeping, wailing and gnashing their teeth.

Smarting from staggering losses in last fall's congressional elections, Illinois Democrats are using their control over the reapportionment process to reverse the results.

In doing so, Democratic map-makers not only are taking revenge on their Republican rivals but trying to set the stage for their party to win back control of the U.S. House of Representatives.

That, in a nutshell, explains the gerrymandered congressional map passed this week by the Illinois General Assembly.

Unfortunately, the partisan machinations once again leave voters on the sidelines as incumbent or aspiring members of the U.S. House try to select their constituents rather than allowing the voters to elect their congressional representatives.

This is no way to produce election maps for state and federal elections, but that is the way the game currently is played in Illinois. The politicians set the rules, and the public pays the bill.

Most local attention has been focused on veteran U.S. Rep. Tim Johnson, an Urbana Republican placed in the new 13th congressional district. Johnson's residence is located at the far eastern edge of a district that runs all the way to the Missouri border, and Democrats think they can beat him on that new turf.

But Johnson is just one Republican incumbent on the Democratic Party's hit list. Most Republican incumbents either find themselves in a district with other incumbents or placed in new districts that map-makers believe are tailor-made to elect Democrats.

In terms of pure gerrymandering skill, it's a work of art.

From a tactical standpoint, the Illinois gerrymander, which Democratic operatives believe could result in picking up six Republican seats, is crucial to their national strategy.

Illinois is one of just seven states where Democrats have complete control of the reapportionment process.

In those other six states, which include Massachusetts, Maryland and Connecticut, Democrats already control 25 of 32 congressional seats.

But in Illinois, Republicans have a 11-8 majority in the state's congressional delegation, creating the possibility of a very rich harvest if the Democratic gerrymander is successful.

U.S. Rep. Steve Israel, chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, said big pickups in Illinois are crucial if Democrats are to win the 24 seats they need to regain their majority in the U.S. House of Representatives.

Gerrymanders, of course, are not always successful. Last fall, Republican U.S. Rep. Bobby Schilling, defeated 17th District incumbent U.S. Rep. Phil Hare in one of the most grossly gerrymandered Democratic districts in Illinois history. Shifting demographics and voter moods can't always be predicted with accuracy.

Nonetheless, what's been done in Illinois is obvious, and the courts are unlikely to do anything to change it.

Democrats, naturally, are gleeful as they anticipate electoral advances.

Republicans are inconsolable as they study the shifting sands and contemplate their bleak futures.

But elections are not just about the political elite. Unfortunately, what's best for the voters, in terms of real choices and competitive elections, isn't a subject that draws much concern when the partisan political map-makers go to work.

Categories (2):Editorials, Opinions

Comments

News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

sacrophyte wrote on June 03, 2011 at 9:06 am

Instead of merely griping about a situation most citizens are already aware of, why not inform readers how to change the system. Myself, I would much prefer to read about how to get involved and how political involvement is actually worthwhile. I believe Johnson is on the so-called hitlist because he has been very effective at what he does. I think.

jthartke wrote on June 03, 2011 at 10:06 am

Firstly, I have to say that this congressional map is FAR more contiguous and representative of the state than the previous one full of Paisleys and the the letter "E". That one was drawn by the incumbents, with a great deal of input from Republicans because who was the Rep drawn out ten years ago? Democrat David Phelps, who Johnson had drawn into his district in order to pick him off. Hurts when its one of your own, doesn't it?

Also, could someone please point out to a major bill sponsored by Tim Johnson? Can you show me the causes he's fought for? Can you show his appearances on national television fighting for our district? Can you explain why he supported the wars, until a Democrat was elected president? John Shimkus is far more effective, and that is a difficult comparison.

And the NG is about to loose all credibility on the redistricting issue. Maps that produce Republican majorities, like the first few produced by our county's "non-partisan" commission, are representative of the people. Yet if they produce Democratic majorities, they are a "public disservice" no matter how contiguous they are, or how "blue" this state and county may be.

Maybe the solution is to go to a proportional representation system, rather than a direct representation system. That way we never have to draw districts again -- AND new parties like the Greens, the Libertarians, and even the precious Tea Party could break the back of the two party monopoly on power.

Yatiri wrote on June 03, 2011 at 10:06 am

It is true that the NG outrage depends on who is doing the gerrymandering.

Locally when Rick Winkel was engaged in map drawing the NG didn't even use the word gerrymander once. Al Kurtz's protest statement wasn't even published.

When the Dems won out in the sleaze contest the NG suddenly is outraged. Very hollow and very partisan outrage by the NG.

WiltonDiary wrote on June 04, 2011 at 2:06 pm

Pleae name one thing Tim Johnson has ever done for this district. Other than call everyone once a year while on his treadmill. Thank to Johnson Rantoul lost Chantue Air Force base and the clean-coal initiative went elsewhere. He represents a party with only two solutions, cut taxes and start wars.

10 years and 10 Tri$$ion in Tax cuts = 10% unemployment!

News by Date