Tate: We'd be silly to count out Paterno again

Tate: We'd be silly to count out Paterno again

Every time Joe Paterno appears to be dazed and on the ropes, he comes back swinging.

His critics were gaining strength a decade ago when Penn State hit a five-year lull in which it missed four bowl games and went 26-33.

But the Nittany Lions caught fire again in 2005, losing only to Michigan 27-25 in an 11-1 campaign, and they produced 11-2 records in 2008 and 2009. Not bad, huh?

And yet, at age 84 and with his body feeling crankiness from recent hip and knee injuries, Paterno seemed far removed from the action as he sat in the press box, seemingly just watching and not connected by a headphone, while Alabama punished his athletes for the second year in a row. The margin in consecutive Alabama losses is 51-14. The Nittany Lions, 7-6 last year, were hammered by Illinois 33-13 and now have lost four of their last six games, with the only wins against Indiana and Indiana State.

Paterno calls coaching "an incentive to be in good health" and says he has recovered sufficiently from knee and hip problems to once again take morning walks. He still may be the dominant voice in the film room and weeklong planning sessions. He remains the CEO, and Rivals.com has Penn State No. 14 in recruiting with 17 commitments of which seven have four-star ratings.

But the assistants are doing nearly all the coaching on game day. And the voices in opposition are starting to rise again.

Of Saturday's trek to Philadelphia, Paterno appeared to exaggerate when he said: "This is the best Temple team I've seen in 60 years ... more physical than any, solid across the board."

Truth is, this may not be the walkover game that it has been the last five years. But regardless of how Saturday turns out, the schedule setup favors Penn State to be bowl eligible before finishing against Illinois, Nebraska, Ohio State and Wisconsin.

Sweet home Chicago

Everybody keeps trying to "take Chicago," and nobody is winning. It's a pro town, and college football only matters when Notre Dame is good. There are those of us who remember, in a bygone day, Chicago Tribune scribes in the UI press box with their radios tuned to the Notre Dame game while covering the Illini. That revealed all you needed to know.

Northwestern has the geographical edge but, for all the costly advertising and billboards, the Wildcats drew 28,042 for Saturday's 42-21 defeat of Eastern Illinois in Evanston.

Iowa was the last Big Ten team to play in the Bears' playpen, beating Northern Illinois 16-3 in 2007. This week it is Wisconsin's turn to try, coach Bret Bielema saying the Badgers used the Iowa contract as a guide for Saturday's game against Northern Illinois at Soldier Field.

"This is a unique opportunity," said Bielema, mindful that it is NIU's home game ... but not really.

"We're hoping for a great crowd for college football. We were concerned about the field conditions, but we're told the turf is solid. This gives our athletes a chance to play in a pro venue and is easy driving distance for our fans."

Illinois tried it in 1994, Lou Tepper's last bowl team falling in the opener to Washington State 10-9 in front of a Soldier Field crowd announced at 39,472. It had nowhere near the electric atmosphere of the UI-Northwestern game last season at Wrigley Field, and the Illini haven't tried the Soldier Field experiment since.

Back at it

While you're at it, explain this one:

Nebraska's Cornhuskers rumbled into Seattle last September and ran all over Washington. Bo Pelini's gang of marauders reeled off 383 yards on the ground and accumulated 49 points by the middle of the third quarter before coasting in with the reserves, 56-21.

This could be described as a laugher. Nebraska was overwhelmingly superior.

And yet, when these same teams met again Dec. 30 in the Holiday Bowl, the underdog Huskies stuffed Nebraska's vaunted attack and won a clear-cut 19-7 decision. Nebraska totaled more penalty yards (102) than either rushing (91) or passing (98).

Saturday will be the rubber match in one of two important Big Ten vs. Pac-12 games (Illinois-Arizona State is the other),

"There'll be a lot of familiarity in our game, and the motivation should be there," Pelini said, "but like everybody else, we have a game plan. At the end of the day, it'll come down to execution. We've been inconsistent, but we found a way Saturday (a comeback 42-29 win against Fresno)."

Touted quarterback Taylor Martinez had a shaky aerial game (10 of 21 with two interceptions) but ran for 166 yards.

Big Ten tidbits

— Luke Fickell will take "10 to 12 guys from the Miami area" back close to home for Ohio State's trip to Miami. But Buckeye Nation is concerned about a native Ohioan. Ballyhooed freshman Braxton Miller threw no passes in the nervous 27-22 win against Toledo, Fickell preferring to stick with senior Joe Bauserman. Fickell said he has a plan for both quarterbacks Saturday.

— If any team is headed for a letdown, it might be Michigan. The passions released in Saturday night's stunning defeat of Notre Dame will make it hard to refocus against a 2-0 Eastern Michigan team. Everyone up North still is talking about the "fun atmosphere" of that contest and the remarkable pass-catching show by Wolverines receivers.

— Whether he plays against Army on Saturday, Northwestern star Dan Persa (Achilles' heel) is expected to be available for the Big Ten opener Oct. 1 at Illinois. Meanwhile, Northwestern coach Pat Fitzgerald is deep into preparations for Army, noting: "This is a completely different, non-traditional challenge. We won't face anything this season that tests us schematically like this triple option. They dominated the ball against San Diego State (403 yards rushing) but lost 23-20 because of three lost fumbles. They're different defensively, too. They load the box and dare you to throw."

— Aware that his Hoosiers are last in Big Ten rushing, Indiana coach Kevin Wilson acknowledged: "We lack a physical presence, and we need our running backs to get more yards after contact. We are behind in that area." Indiana is also last in rushing defense.

Loren Tate writes for The News-Gazette. He can be reached at ltate@news-gazette.com.

Categories (3):Illini Sports, Football, Sports


News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

keno wrote on September 14, 2011 at 10:09 pm

Thanks Loren. this is a bold new line of thinking on the Chicago question, conveniently omitting nothing about Guenther's Thursday night failure at Soldier.

sagan20 wrote on September 15, 2011 at 7:09 am

I agree with your Chicago comments. If we can't get every single Chicago sports fan excited about Illinois football, what's the point to even trying there? By the way, the "Soldier Field experiment" was on a Thursday night (before there was such a thing as Thursday night college football) thanks to our wonderful ex AD.

IlliniOllie wrote on September 15, 2011 at 8:09 am

"Everybody keeps trying to 'take Chicago,' and nobody is winning."

Everybody? If you were Illinois under Ron "88-132-2" Guenther, you weren't even trying.

Actually, if you were Ron Guenther, you were actively working against capturing the Chicago market, by doing things like moving the Illini to low-power, obnoxious WIND because some mean person on the Score made fun of someone and you got your poor widdle feelings hurt. Or by not advertising in the market at all.

You have to actually try to "take Chicago" before you can fail at it.

muckfichigan wrote on September 15, 2011 at 3:09 pm

I'm sure new AD Mike Thomas will make good on his promise not to cede the Chicago territory to Northwestern or any other school for that matter. It makes sense to schedule one home game a year there for obvious reasons given the alumni base, and also makes sense given the ambivalence of fans in central illinois. Maybe he takes a page out of the Packers book, and makes two games a year available there. Might create more demand in CU for home games. I distinctly remember the paltry 45,000 that showed up on a beautiful Thanksgiving day against Northwestern for the Big Ten championship. Saturday night's game would be sold out in most college towns.