UFR: A staff infection

We asked Paul Klee to break down Saturday's 45-0 loss at Michigan.

First Impressions

— Strap in, buckle up, get a grip. This could get worse before it gets better. Saturday’s 45-point loss was a low point, but it might not be the low point. That could arrive when Illinois enters a 2013 schedule that is more unkind than this one. Over three Big Ten games, Illinois has been torched by an average of 30 points. And this freefall is coming within a mediocre year for Big Ten football. Next season the Big Ten figures to stiffen — it always does — and the Illinois schedule is set up for failure. The so-called winnable games (Indiana, Purdue) are on the road, for one. And next year’s team also could be without NFL prospects Michael Buchanan, Terry Hawthorne and Akeem Spence. What develops in February, when Tim Beckman signs his second recruiting class, is more important than what happens to finish this season.

— The question isn’t whether Beckman can recover from this four-game losing streak and right the sinking ship this season. It’s whether he can recover at all. Perception too often is reality, and the public perception of the first-year staff is as negative as we’ve seen with a first-year staff. There was never a honeymoon. Seven games in, some ticket buyers already want a divorce. Fixing the broken football program won’t be the toughest job in the DIA. At this pace, that honor goes to selling football tickets for the 2013 season.

— Through the first quarter Saturday, Michigan’s players appeared content to dance and jive and sprint past Illini defenders. Once the Wolverines realized they could run over them, too, the hosts turned into merciless bullies. Fitzgerald Toussaint punished a defensive back who dared to challenge his running lane. Thomas Rawls saw no running lane, so he created one with a powerful shoulder. Michigan beat Illinois worse than Illinois beat Charleston Southern; the talent differential was as obvious as the rain that drenched Michigan Stadium. That must be a significant consideration as critics judge Beckman’s first season. “Coach is a strong individual. He understands that Rome wasn’t built in a day,” defensive coordinator Tim Banks said. “That’s why we’re here.”

— Credit the Illini for disregarding the injury excuse. Supo Sanni, who has been one of the injured, said the list of injuries shouldn’t be considered an alibi for the blowout defeats. So did Graham Pocic. “It’s embarrassing,” he said simply. One of the most important players joined the walking wounded on the sideline Saturday. Yet Hawthorne maintained a positive approach during a tough-to-stomach game. When fellow defensive back Justin Green batted away a pass, Hawthorne (concussion) jumped into the air and shouted his approval. “I thought Terry did a great job on the sidelines,” Beckman said. “He knew he wasn’t going to play. We asked him to be a leader.”

Second Guessing

— Any criticisms leveled in the direction of Nathan Scheelhaase are off the mark. The third-year starter hardly has a chance; when he’s not scrambling to avoid pressure, receivers often are dropping his passes. Before he was knocked from Saturday’s game with a concussion, Scheelhaase made one of the better plays for Illinois. On a third and long, he avoided the pass rush for just long enough to fire a pass to Darius Millines. It hit Millines right between the numbers but bounced to the turf. All told, Michigan tripled Illinois in first downs (21-7) and quadrupled the Illini in total yards (527-134). The Illini never advanced beyond the Michigan 32-yard line.

— It’s fair to question the Illini’s decision to attempt a long field goal early in the second quarter. Considering the conditions (wet and getting wetter), an inexperienced kicker (redshirt freshman Taylor Zalewski), the score (10-0 Michigan) and the length of the kick (50 yards), it seemed more advantageous to pin the Wolverines with a punt. Instead, the kick missed right, and Michigan began another touchdown drive.

Third Degree

— The team up north is bowl eligible again. Northwestern won its sixth game with a 21-13 victory at Minnesota and will play in a bowl for the fifth straight season. The Wildcats are opportunistic and plucky, with four of those wins coming by 10 points or less.

— How does Jerry Kill make it work in spite of a scary health condition? His staff is a big reason. Kill suffered another seizure Saturday and reportedly was resting comfortably in a Minneapolis hospital. I witnessed this scenario when Kill was at SIU; his system was so firmly entrenched, his staff so tight, the Salukis didn’t skip a beat during one of Kill’s midseason setbacks. The coordinators — Tracy Claeys and Matt Limegrover — have been with Kill since the 1990s. Position coaches Brian Anderson, Pat Poore, Jay Sawvel and Rob Reeves all were on his staff at SIU. The continuity has allowed them to succeed even as the head coach battles his health condition. Continuity within a staff often is undervalued.

In the Stadium

— He’s been the Dee Brown of Michigan football, his highlights, style and smile almost bigger than the program. But where will Denard Robinson fit next season in the NFL? As spectacular as Robinson can be on the ground, his professional future isn’t at quarterback.

“A lot of that will depend on what he wants or what he wants to try to play (quarterback). Whether the NFL thinks he’s a quarterback or not, if he feels he doesn’t want to play anything other than quarterback, he’s not going to,” said Michael Rothstein, who covers Michigan for wolverinenationespn.com. “I actually talked to Antwaan Randle El this week and he said, ‘Yeah, he’s probably going to be a wide receiver.’ His career path would look a lot like Antwaan Randle El or a guy like Brad Smith or Josh Cribbs.
“Those are great models for what Denard Robinson could be in the NFL. He’s as fast if not faster than all those guys. But as a quarterback he certainly hasn’t shown the accuracy on long passes or out routes that you need to play in the NFL.”

— Illinois officials toured Crisler Center on Saturday morning to get a peek at Michigan basketball’s upgrades. Athletic director Mike Thomas said it was helpful to see an older facility that had been renovated, instead of a new arena built from the ground up. As part of the changes to the basketball arena, available seating shrunk by 1,000 seats.

— Prior to kickoff, Michigan unretired the No. 48 jersey of former President Gerald Ford. Yes, unretired. Michigan is honoring its legends by putting their retired jerseys back on the field. Sophomore linebacker Desmond Morgan switched from No. 44 to Ford’s 48.

— In the stadium, the attendance was announced at 110,922. “The largest crowd to watch a football game in the country today,” the P.A. announcer said. The announced attendance through four home games this season at Memorial Stadium: 182,084.

Categories (3):Illini Sports, Football, Sports

Comments

News-Gazette.com embraces discussion of both community and world issues. We welcome you to contribute your ideas, opinions and comments, but we ask that you avoid personal attacks, vulgarity and hate speech. We reserve the right to remove any comment at our discretion, and we will block repeat offenders' accounts. To post comments, you must first be a registered user, and your username will appear with any comment you post. Happy posting.

Login or register to post comments

FloridaIllini wrote on October 14, 2012 at 9:10 am

Beckman and his group have obviously lost the heart and mind of the players.  I would really like to know what he did or ddn't do when he took over that so completely turned the players against them.  Every group has it's leaders.  Beckman must have done something terribly wrong in working with them.  I can live with a poor record.  Illini fans know what that feels like.  What I can't live with is when I feel the new coach has lost the team so early in his tenure.  Something is dreadfully wrong in the locker room and it's not losing.  It's what the coaches have done to the team.

Moonpie wrote on October 14, 2012 at 10:10 am

Or perhaps Beckman has inherited players missing hearts and minds. I doubt Urban Meyer could win with this bunch -- or the vaunted Vic Koening.


How bad is it? I have to agree with an Obi Wan Tate column. That's how bad it is.

illini82 wrote on October 14, 2012 at 11:10 am

I see this as Gary Moeller part 2. It's getting worse every week with no measurable improvement in ANY facet of the game. The offense is bad the defense is bad and so are the special teams. I've met Tim Beckman and have heard him speak. Yes he's a nice guy and is or at least was enthusiastic but to me he didn't impress me as one who could lead a team in a major BCS conference like the B10. He didn't strike me as the sharpest knife in the drawer and I'll leave it at that. Plus his ill-thought trip to PSU or at least the way it was handled and the Skoal incident. That's not a good way to endear yourself to fans when your team is tanking. He's out of his league and this will end badly. 


And many are right in that we'll have to put up with this for 2 more years and maybe 3. So how do you think recruiting will go after this? What about ticket sales. I can see another 3000 to 5000 season ticket drop. We may struggle to average 30,000 per game next year. That's Northwestern and Indiana territory. Beckman aka Skoal man is already on the hot seat and Mike Thomas should be right there with him. This is on him. This was his choice and it's obvious Thomas didn't have his ducks in a row when it came time for a change. He flashed an open check book and no one wanted to risk coming here. It's a coaching graveyard here and/or few in the profession want to work for or trust Thomas.


I wish I could say give him time but I just don't see it. This team has given up on the staff, each other and themselves. If things are as bad or worse next year with recruiting also dying then the administration needs to pull the plug on Thomas and Beckman by early November next year. And the administration better start getting a list of AD candidates NOW for that possibility.


To be fair this didn't start with Thomas as the actions or inaction by RG with previous coaches was a major part of where we are now. But it even goes beyond that. The culture at Illinois at the highest levels of the administraton and BOT has been one of apathy and indifferrence since the late 60's. I even remember as a student the sick pride many faculty and even students took in being so poor in sports. As if it was a badge of honor and made us a better academic institution. A Harvard of the west or a larger University of Chicago. Basically at Michigan and Notre Dame football and revenue sports mattered but at Illinois...not so much. 


For me today, I'm almost embarrased to be a an Illinois alum and fan. I'll let the season play out but I'm likely going to give up my season tickets including IFund donations. I've seen enough. It's just not worth the time, money and patience anymore and that is truly sad.

OKOMIS wrote on October 14, 2012 at 7:10 pm

 As bad as the coaching has been, and it’s been bad… Ditka, Lombardi, Belichick, Saban.. same record.. probably not such lopsided losses… but Az St.. La Tech.. Penn State.. Michigan has way better talent.. Give me Beckman with Alabama’s players over Saban with what we got any day… it wouldn’t be close..

CecilColeman wrote on October 14, 2012 at 2:10 pm

Here's an idea - - maybe Neale Stoner would like to come back for a year as a special advisor to Mr. Thomas.  (1) Stoner could help Beckman find connections in the California junior college systems and get some of the recruits making the Oregon and the Washington and the Arizona teams much stronger than the Illinil (2) Stoner could teach Mr. Thomas how to market the program and sell tickets; (3) Stoner could laugh in Tate's and Turpin's faces (Champaign's 1988 answer to Woodward and Bernstein) and tell them to get lost!

bernies wrote on October 14, 2012 at 7:10 pm

Anyone nervous about facing IU in two weeks? Thought this would be a gimme game at the start of the season, but Indiana put up 49 points on OSU this weekend!