Film Critic

Chuck Koplinski is The News-Gazette's film critic. His email is and you can follow him on Twitter (@ckoplinski).

SR 2019 films
Listen to this article

When film historians look back at 2019, they will note that this was the year when Netflix changed the cinematic landscape for good ... or ill, depending on your point of view.

Until this year, the streaming service had only been a minor disruption on the movie landscape by producing its own fare, acquiring others’ work or buying the big studios’ castoffs (“The Cloverfield Paradox,” anyone?) before dipping its toe in the Oscar race with a multimillion-dollar push behind Alfonso Cuaron’s “Roma.” It ultimately took home three of the gold statuettes but failed to nab the top prize, best picture.

This year, Netflix will not be deterred, as it has two likely best-picture nominees (“The Irishman” and “Marriage Story”) and a marketing team of 60 that will move heaven and earth to make sure those films stay in the spotlight until the ceremony on Feb. 9.

The fact that Netflix now has north of 160 million monthly subscribers, which translates to about $25 billion in subscription funds annually, and that movie attendance has dropped for the 10th straight year, has executives at the big studios sweating. However, the suits at 20th Century Fox no longer have to worry, as they’ve been devoured by the beast that is Disney, the first studio to post annual ticket sales in excess of $10 billion. While the other majors fret, the House of Mouse continues to dominate the market in a way that could ultimately run it afoul of antitrust laws.

Disney, Warner Bros. and other studios are following the “If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em” strategy where the Netflix problem is concerned and are simply starting their own streaming services.

Disney Plus got off to a rousing start, signing on 10 million subscribers in its first month, with projections showing that number will double by year’s end. Its wildly popular content is an obvious draw, but so is its initial price point of $6.99 a month, the most affordable baby sitter you could ever hope to find. Warner Bros. is hitching its star to HBO Max, a division of its studio, and will charge $15.99 a month for access to its vast catalog of films as well as HBO’s programing slate. We’ll have to wait until spring to see if this proves to be a wise strategy.

Perhaps the most disheartening thing about the film year was the quiet death of the mid-budget movie. Today, studios avoid modest, adult fare that may only set them back $25 million to $75 million. They, and their stockholders, are much more interested in betting big, ponying up $200 million or more in the hopes of producing an international hit that will bring in over $1 billion.

Credit Warner Bros. for continuing the mid-budget movie’s lifespan, with “The Goldfinch,” “Doctor Sleep,” “The Good Liar” and “Motherless Brooklyn” all coming in with price tags in the $50 million range. Unfortunately, each of these movies went down in flames at the box office, driving a few more nails into studio-produced adult entertainment.

However, the double-edged sword that is Netflix is more than eager to pick up the mantle, producing “The Two Popes,” “Dolemite is my Name” and “The Irishman,” all of which were cast aside by the majors, only to find a home at the streamer. Yes, the company may be slowly killing the theater-going experience, but it produces films no one else will and that can’t be ignored.

There were films I liked that you didn’t (“Anna,” “The Best of Enemies,” “Booksmart,” “Captive State,” “Dark Waters,” “Fighting with My Family,” “Hellboy,” “Missing Link,” “The Prodigy”), movies you liked that I didn’t (“Breakthrough,” “Glass,” “It Chapter 2,” “The Lion King,” “Maleficent: Mistress of Evil,” “The Upside,” “Us”), and those no one liked (“Alita: Battle Agent,” “Charlie’s Angels,” “Cold Pursuit,” “Dark Phoenix,” “The Goldfinch,” “Hustle,” “The Kitchen,” “MIB: International,” “Motherless Brooklyn,” “Serenity,” “Stuber”).

In making this year’s “Best Of” list, one thing that struck me was that there was only one film that cracked the top 10 that was produced by a major studio. Almost every movie below was an independent production distributed with no help from the major studios. Risk-taking is over at Warner Bros., Paramount, Sony and MGM, and their bland fare is hardly proving successful. Yes, this is the dawning of the Netflix Era — and perhaps the beginning of the end of the Hollywood studios as we know them.

On to the list ...

‘The Irishman’

SR 2019 films Irishman

With a budget of nearly $160 million, it would seem odd to call Martin Scorsese’s masterpiece a small film. Yet there’s an intimacy to the movie that cuts to the eternal dilemma its titular character, hitman Frank Sheeran (Robert DeNiro) — and by extension the viewer — must contend with. This isn’t simply another gangster movie, but an examination of what happens when you compromise your beliefs and the ultimate toll it takes on your soul. DeNiro has never been better, subtly displaying Sheeran’s anguish as he makes one morally questionable decision after another while climbing the ranks of the Pennsylvania underworld and the Teamsters union. Paired with Joe Pesci, who gives the most quiet yet menacing performance of the year as crime boss Russell Bufalino, and Al Pacino, providing an unexpectedly poignant turn as as Jimmy Hoffa, this is an immersive experience that is perhaps the most emotionally relevant of Scorsese’s works.

‘Uncut Gems’

SR 2019 films Uncut Gems

Brother directors Benny and Josh Safdie are an acquired taste. Their gritty, in-your-face, manic approach overshadowed their first three films, undercutting their hard-edged stories. However, they tone things down enough to allow this tale of small-time hustler Howard Ratner, brilliantly played by Adam Sandler, to resonate. As their anti-hero’s schemes come tumbling down, the directors’ already-intrusive camera bores in further on Sandler, who fills the screen with a sense of misguided bravado and frantic desperation that’s a revelation. Not for all tastes, this is a daring piece of cinema that signals a new and welcome direction for Sandler.

‘Dark Waters’

SR 2019 films Dark Waters

Amidst the many social-justice-themed films released this year, Todd Haynes’ examination of the suit brought against the chemical giant DuPont is the most arresting and infuriating. Mark Ruffalo has never been better as attorney Rob Bilott, a corporate lawyer who reluctantly takes on the case of West Virginia farmer Wilbur Tenant (Bill Camp) who believes the nearby DuPont plant is poisoning his land. Haynes sets out the facts of the case and pulls no punches in stoking a sense of low-simmering fury that drives Bilott, the same fury the viewer can’t help but share once the corporation’s negligence is exposed. Fiery and poignant, this is necessary viewing that speaks to the need to remain vigilant where corporate practices are concerned and proves unshakable.

‘Pain and Glory’

SR 2019 films Pain and Glory

Pedro Almodovar’s semi-autobiographical film has his longtime collaborator Antonio Banderas giving a career-best performance as a filmmaker hobbled by pain, drug addiction and doubt. Far from being a pity party, this is a celebration of the experiences that made him into the artist he becomes, as we are treated to poignant flashbacks focusing on his relationship with his mother (played be Penelope Cruz), as well as scenes from a heartbreaking love affair. Quiet and moving, the filmmaker’s ultimate triumph comes from taking stock of himself and, most importantly, asking for help in order to get back on his feet once more.

‘American Woman’

SR 2019 films American Woman

The best movie you didn’t see this year features an incredibly dynamic, fierce performance from Sienna Miller as Deb, a woman who never grew up but is forced to change her life when her daughter goes missing and she’s left to raise her grandson. The film takes place over 15 years, and Deb’s journey is a distinctly American one, as she remakes herself into a woman who can be depended on, as well as a person who takes joy in helping others, rather than simply focusing on herself. A hidden gem, this is well worth seeking out.


SR 2019 films MIdsommar

While I felt that writer/director Ari Aster’s “Hereditary” (2018) was one of the most overrated horror films in recent memory, Midsommar is one of the best. Florence Pugh gives a raw, daring performance as a lost young woman who finds herself in the most unexpected of places — a Swedish summer-solstice ceremony that has dark undercurrents she and her fellow outsiders are cruelly unaware of. Aster takes his time, steadily building a sense of dread as he ingratiates his characters and viewers into this seemingly non-threatening environment, only to reveal a culture that adheres to out-of-step notions where life and death are concerned. Vividly driving home the dangers of not questioning the status quo, this is a movie that resonates far after the end credits roll.

‘Brittany Runs a Marathon’

SR 2019 films Brittany Runs

Promoted as a quirky comedy, Paul Colaizzo’s film is a tale of personal redemption in which a young woman takes stock of her life and successfully pulls herself out of a pit of self-loathing. Jillian Bell gives an unexpectedly moving performance as Brittany, progressively finding her footing after contending with one setback after another, going from being everyone’s doormat to a self-assured woman brimming with confidence. Surprisingly moving, this was one of Amazon Studios’ few bright spots this year.

‘The Mustang’

SR 2019 films Mustang

Based on a real rehabilitation program in which inmates are given a wild horse to tame, this film is driven by Matthias Schoenaerts’ simmering performance as a convict desperately trying to make things right with his estranged daughter. The relationship he forms with his horse, Marquis, evolves into one of mutual understanding, as these two initially test each other before recognizing they’re cut from the same cloth. Moving and haunting, the movie’s final image has stayed with me the entire year.


SR 2019 films Diane

Criminally underseen, this indie from writer/director Kent Jones was written especially for actor Mary Kay Place, who takes the meaty titular role and runs with it. Set in Pennsylvania, Diane lives a life of quiet regret and desperation, helping others in her community as a sort of self-imposed penance for perceived sins from her past. As she tries to reconcile with her drug-addicted son, she winds up finding the solace she needs in the most unexpected of places. A true slice-of-life, Place brings this common woman we all know to life, giving us pause to realize that those we often overlook or take for granted are worthy of our love and empathy.

‘Avengers: Endgame’

SR 2019 films Avengers Endgame

With apologies to Martin Scorsese, I simply have to include the final chapter of Marvel Films’ 22-movie saga, a conclusion that simply could not have been executed any better. Audience expectations were met not simply from the standpoint of visual spectacle, but more importantly, in the emotional payoff that resulted from seeing the journey of the superhero characters we’ve come to know and love come to a satisfying end. No other movie had the epic feel of this grand adventure, which was bolstered by the emotional investment the studio nurtured so effectively.

Tied for 11th Place

— Noah Baumbach’s heartbreaking and ultimately hopeful “Marriage Story.”

— Kenneth Branagh’s revisionist Shakespeare tale “All is True.”

— Olivia Wilde’s poignant and knowing “Booksmart.”

— Danny Boyle’s musical fantasy “Yesterday.”

— Julius Onah’s shocking and timely tale of modern teens “Luce.”

— Chris Butler’s beautiful and touching “Missing Link.”

— Taika Waititi’s sharp-edged satire about Nazi Germany “Jojo Rabbit.”

— James Mangold’s thrilling buddy film “Ford v Ferrari.”

— Marielle Heller’s much-needed and moving “A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood.”

— Rupert Evert’s criminally underseen sci-fi parable “Captive State.”

— Claire McCarthy’s clever Hamlet re-do “Ophelia.”

For DVR alerts, film recommendations and movie news, follow Koplinski on Twitter (@ckoplinski). He can be reached via email at